Define acceptance before calculating cost
In this guide, accepted means the firm’s designated reviewer has recorded a decision to accept a matter. Delivery, a connected call, a signed agreement, and onboarding are separate events. Your firm should document its acceptance definition and apply it consistently across suppliers.
The basic formula is: supplier cost per accepted case = (attributable supplier charges − confirmed applicable credits) ÷ unique accepted matters. The numerator and denominator must refer to the same cohort and reporting date.
Check whether a lead-cost benchmark adds up
When the spend, cohort and measurement date are the same, cost per signed case equals cost per lead divided by the share of those leads that signed. Divide by the share of those same leads accepted by the firm to calculate cost per accepted case. Enter percentages as decimals: 10% is 0.10.
Consider this invented example: a firm spends $20,000 on 100 unique leads, 10 sign a retainer and 8 are accepted by the firm. These are illustrative inputs, not CaseLead prices, results or market benchmarks. Assume no credits or additional intake costs, and no pending acceptance decisions among the signed matters.
- A quoted $500 cost per signed case would not reconcile with $200 per lead and a 10% signing rate for this same cohort and cost basis. Ask which spend, dates or denominators differ.
- An 80% signed-to-accepted rate uses signed matters as its denominator. Dividing cost per lead by 80% would give the wrong result. Use the 8% lead-to-accepted rate or apply both stages: $200 / (0.10 x 0.80).
- Separately averaged firm-level metrics may not reconcile like one pooled cohort. Request the underlying counts, spend and weighting method before treating a published benchmark as your forecast.
- Confirm charges, credits and review maturity first. If costs differ between stages, calculate each result directly from its attributable cost and count rather than combining incompatible ratios.
| Measure | Calculation | Illustrative result |
|---|---|---|
| Cost per lead | $20,000 / 100 leads | $200 |
| Lead-to-signed rate | 10 signed / 100 leads | 10% |
| Cost per signed case | $200 / 0.10 | $2,000 |
| Lead-to-accepted rate | 8 accepted / 100 leads | 8% |
| Signed-to-accepted rate | 8 accepted / 10 signed | 80% |
| Cost per accepted case | $200 / 0.08, or $2,000 / 0.80 | $2,500 |
Create one cohort of unique delivered matters
A practical cohort is every unique matter first delivered during a calendar month. Record a stable matter identifier, first delivery date, supplier, delivery model, and the criteria version that applied. Choose a rule for duplicates and replacements before producing the report.
Count a matter once even if the packet is updated or resent. If a replacement is a different matter, link it to the original and show its treatment explicitly. Do not count a free replacement as an extra paid unit or erase the original review record.
Keep later acceptance decisions attached to the original delivery cohort. A report built from this month’s spending and this month’s acceptances across unrelated delivery periods will not measure a consistent acquisition group.
Reconcile charges, credits, and internal work
Include supplier charges attributable to the cohort, including setup or other fees when applicable. If a fee spans multiple periods, document the allocation rule and apply it consistently. Report the calculation on a charges basis; payment timing can be shown separately.
Subtract only confirmed applicable credits or refunds, counted once against the relevant charges. Keep requested, disputed, and unconfirmed credits in a separate field. If an invoice already includes a credit, do not subtract it again.
For a broader measure, add attributable intake labor and other acquisition expenses. Show what is included and how it was allocated. Keep supplier-only and broader costs separately labeled so a reader can compare equivalent measures.
Start with the price of the acquisition service
Two anonymized engagements show how an acquisition purchase can be structured. In the recurring engagement, the opening 10-unit order was $3,000 per billed unit; the next 140 units were $3,250 each. In the defined assignment, 70 billed units at $3,400 each totaled $238,000, paid through three funding installments.
Use those records to compare purchase size, included work and payment terms. To calculate cost per accepted matter for your firm, match attributable charges and confirmed credits to unique delivered matters and the firm’s recorded acceptance decisions. The historical prices alone cannot supply that denominator.
| Historical purchase | Billed units | Recorded service purchase (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| Six recurring MVA orders | 150 | $485,000 |
| One defined MVA order | 70 | $238,000 |
Worked example: a hypothetical delivery cohort
The following invented figures demonstrate the method. They are not CaseLead prices, customer results, or forecasts. Assume all listed charges relate to the same 20 unique matters and all amounts are in US dollars.
| Cohort item at the first report date | Hypothetical value |
|---|---|
| Unique matters delivered | 20 |
| Accepted | 12 |
| Declined | 5 |
| Pending review | 3 |
| Supplier delivery charges | $29,000 |
| Allocated supplier setup fee | $1,000 |
| Total attributable supplier charges | $30,000 |
| Confirmed applicable credits | $3,000 |
| Additional requested credit, not confirmed | $1,000 |
| Net supplier cost | $27,000 |
| Attributable intake labor | $3,600 |
Reproduce the first report
First reconcile the review statuses: 12 accepted + 5 declined + 3 pending = 20 unique delivered matters. Signature status is a separate field and is not added to those mutually exclusive review statuses.
Net supplier cost is $30,000 − $3,000 = $27,000. The additional $1,000 requested credit is excluded because it is not confirmed. Supplier cost per accepted case is $27,000 ÷ 12 = $2,250.
Broader acquisition cost including the stated intake labor is ($27,000 + $3,600) ÷ 12 = $2,550 per accepted case. The accepted share of all delivered matters is 12 ÷ 20 = 60%. Of the 17 matters with a completed review, 12 ÷ 17 is approximately 70.6%; label that resolved-review rate separately. Neither percentage resolves the three pending matters.
Update the same cohort as reviews mature
Suppose two pending matters are later accepted and one is declined. The same cohort now contains 14 accepted, 6 declined, and none pending. Suppose the additional $1,000 credit is also confirmed and the firm records another $400 of attributable intake labor.
Confirmed credits now total $4,000, so net supplier cost becomes $30,000 − $4,000 = $26,000. Supplier cost per accepted case is $26,000 ÷ 14 = $1,857.14, rounded to cents. Total intake labor is $4,000, making the broader cost ($26,000 + $4,000) ÷ 14 = $2,142.86.
Preserve both dated snapshots. The difference reflects later review decisions, a confirmed credit, and additional labor. It does not demonstrate a change in supplier performance between two delivery periods.
Keep pending decisions out of the accepted denominator
Pending matters are unresolved, not accepted or declined. Show their count, age, and next review owner. State whether the reported cost is provisional and schedule the next cohort update using the firm’s review process.
If you model what would happen if pending matters were accepted, label the result as a scenario and keep it separate from actuals. Do not place forecast acceptances in the reported denominator. Similarly, do not assume every pending credit will be approved.
If there are no acceptances, report an undefined cost
When accepted matters equal zero, cost per accepted case is undefined. Do not report $0, divide by delivered matters as a substitute, or insert a placeholder acceptance. Show net spend and the accepted, declined, and pending counts instead.
For example, a hypothetical cohort with $5,000 net supplier cost, zero accepted, two declined, and three pending should read: “Cost per accepted case: undefined; $5,000 net supplier cost; 0 accepted, 2 declined, 3 pending.” If later reviews produce acceptances, update that same cohort.
Keep an audit trail a second reviewer can follow
A useful report links the summary to matter records and cost entries. A second person should be able to reproduce the counts, allocations, and credits without guessing what an invoice line or status means.
- Cohort identifier, delivery window, reporting date, and acceptance definition.
- Unique matter ID, first delivery date, current review status, decision date, and reason.
- Charges, fee allocation, confirmed credits, open credit requests, and supporting references.
- Supplier-only formula, separately stated internal costs, rounding rule, and dated revisions.
Use the metric for the decision it can support
Cost per accepted case helps compare acquisition arrangements when handoff stages and billing triggers differ. Read it alongside cohort size, pending reviews, criteria, and internal workload. Differences in case profile or review timing can make two numbers poor comparisons.
Track recovered fees, case expenses, and time to payment separately when assessing longer-term economics. Keep the accepted-case calculation tied to the cohort and review date so your team can compare acquisition decisions consistently.
Take the working files to your review
Free downloads. No email or account required. Keep client information in your firm’s approved systems.
- Intake capacity worksheet · Excel
Plan the hours your firm needs for first contact, follow-up and document review. Editable inputs and a clearly fictional example.
- Invoice, credit and replacement reconciliation · Excel
Match original charges, confirmed credits and replacement links without counting the same adjustment twice. Includes a fictional cost reconciliation.
- Lead source attribution map and history · Excel
Keep original source, provider, delivery cohort and later touches distinct. Use a field map and change history to repair overwritten source records.
- Acquisition cohort comparison · Excel
Compare two delivery groups with explicit review cutoffs, pending counts and cost definitions. Identify differences that prevent a fair performance conclusion.
Questions law firms ask
Should pending cases be counted as accepted?
No. Keep them in a separate pending category until the firm records a decision. Report cost as provisional when unresolved reviews could change the denominator.
Can we subtract a credit we have requested?
Keep requested credits separate until confirmed. Subtract an applicable confirmed credit once, ensuring it has not already reduced the charge total.
Is cost per accepted case the same as cost per signed case?
No. Signed and accepted are different events. Calculate each using its own defined denominator and label them clearly.
Does a lower cost per accepted case prove better profitability?
No. Profitability also depends on subsequent revenue, timing, case expenses, and other costs. Acceptance-based acquisition metrics do not establish those outcomes.
How do we check a quoted cost per lead against cost per signed case?
For the same cohort, spend and reporting date, divide cost per lead by the lead-to-signed rate expressed as a decimal. In an illustrative example, $200 per lead divided by 0.10 equals $2,000 per signed case. A different quoted result needs an explanation of costs, cohorts, weighting or conversion definitions. Firm acceptance requires its own denominator.
Agree on measurement before the first delivery
Discuss the delivery scope, billing trigger, review process, and reporting fields your firm needs.
Discuss your buying requirements