Answering service, intake service and signed cases compared
The difference is how far each one takes the claimant before your firm takes over.
| What differs | Answering service | Intake service | Signed-case provider |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who makes the phone ring | Your marketing | Your marketing | The provider’s own advertising |
| What its staff do | Answer, take a message, transfer or book a consultation | Ask your screening questions, check conflicts, send and follow up the retainer | Find, screen and sign the claimant on your firm’s agreement |
| What reaches your firm | A message or a live caller | A screened caller, often with a retainer sent or signed | A signed client and the intake file |
| What you pay for | Minutes or calls, monthly | Minutes, calls or signed retainers | Each signed case |
| Published 2026 prices | From $99 for 50 minutes (PATLive) or $300 for 30 calls (Smith.ai) | Alert Communications: $590 a month for 250 minutes with intake, or $575 plus $75 per signed retainer | About $1,775–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer; CaseLead $2,800–$3,800 |
| Your team still does | Screening, follow-up, signing and the case | Judging borderline cases and the case itself | Reviewing the file and the case itself |
When an answering service is enough
An answering service fits a firm whose own staff screen and sign well but cannot cover every hour. It catches the caller at night and on weekends, takes the details and puts the strongest calls through live. Most bill by the minute or the call, so a long intake script costs more than a short message.
Check what its staff are allowed to do on your plan: some only take messages, while others ask your questions, check conflicts and book consultations on your calendar.
When to use an intake service
An intake service fits a firm that buys or generates enough inquiries but loses them between the first call and the signature. Its staff work your script, check conflicts, send the retainer for e-signature and follow up until it is signed or declined. Alert Communications, which serves law firms only, publishes this as a plan: $575 a month plus $75 per signed retainer, with retainers sent by DocuSign. Smith.ai’s personal injury page says it sends retainers on the call.
ABA Formal Opinion 506 (2023) says a lawyer may train and supervise non-lawyers to take intake information, run an initial conflict check and obtain the prospective client’s signature on the fee agreement, provided the client is always offered the chance to talk to the lawyer. Non-lawyers may not advise on what legal services to obtain, negotiate fees or interpret the agreement. Read the script and listen to sample calls before you start.
When to buy signed cases
A signed-case provider fits a firm that wants clients without running the advertising or the intake. It pays for the marketing and the people, and charges per signed case: Injury Case Claims publishes signed MVA retainers from $1,775, First Intent Leads quotes by market by state, RingOnDemand $2,500, and CaseLead Agency $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed retainer.
Paying per signed client is restricted in some states. Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 18-1, New Jersey ACPE Opinion 741 and New York State Bar Opinions 1279 and 1294 treat a fee owed only when a client signs as a referral fee, while Illinois has allowed a reasonable per-hire fee under conditions since July 1, 2025. Have your ethics counsel review the billable event.
Which fits your firm?
Start from what is failing today.
- Calls go to voicemail after hours: an answering service
- Calls are answered but few sign: an intake service, or better scripts and follow-up in-house
- Too few calls in the first place: more marketing, or signed cases
- No time to build either: signed cases, at a known price per client
- Many firms combine them: their own marketing and intake by day, an answering service at night, and signed cases to fill capacity
Compare them on cost per signed case
An answering or intake service looks cheap until you add the marketing that produces the calls. Add your ad spend, the service’s fee and your staff time, subtract credits, and divide by the clients who signed. Set that number beside a per-case price. If yours is lower and steady, keep running your own intake; if it is higher, or you cannot keep the phones covered, buying signed cases may cost less.
CaseLead Agency runs paid acquisition, qualifies callers by telephone, completes human intake and coordinates the claimant’s signature on your firm’s own retainer, at $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer.
Questions law firms ask
What is the difference between a legal answering service and an intake service?
An answering service takes the call and follows your script, ending with a message, a transfer or a booking. An intake service screens the caller against your case criteria, checks conflicts, and usually sends the retainer and follows up until it is signed.
Do answering services sign clients?
Few do. Of 15 legal answering services we checked on November 12, 2026, Alert Communications publishes a price per signed retainer ($75 on its Premier plan), and Smith.ai’s personal injury page says it sends retainers on the call.
Is a signed-case provider the same as an intake service?
No. An intake service works the calls your marketing produces. A signed-case provider also runs the advertising that finds the claimant, and charges per signed client.
Which is cheapest?
Per month, an answering service. Per signed client, it depends on your marketing cost and how many callers sign. Work out your own cost per signed case before comparing.
Can non-lawyer intake staff sign clients?
Under ABA Formal Opinion 506 (2023), trained and supervised non-lawyers may obtain a prospective client’s signature on the fee agreement, if the client is always offered the chance to talk to the lawyer. They may not give legal advice, negotiate fees or interpret the agreement. Check your state’s version of the rules.
Sources and further reading
- Alert Communications, plans (checked November 12, 2026)
- Smith.ai, personal injury law (checked November 12, 2026)
- ABA Formal Opinion 506, nonlawyer assistants in intake (2023), as hosted by the Louisiana Attorney Disciplinary Board
- Smith.ai, receptionist pricing (checked November 12, 2026)
- Injury Case Claims advertised starting price — selected offer checked 2026-11-17
- First Intent program and quote details — selected offer checked 2026-11-17
- RingOnDemand, MVA prices (checked November 3, 2026)
- The Florida Bar, Ethics Opinion 18-1
- Standard retainer pricing and minimum — selected offer checked 2026-11-17
Tell us which cases your firm wants.
Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.
Discuss your case criteria