How does pay per signed case work?
The provider pays for the advertising, screens the claimants and completes intake. The firm pays only the agreed fee for each file that meets the agreed billable event. That moves the cost of claimants who never sign from the firm to the provider.
CaseLead works this way where the rules allow it. We run paid acquisition on Meta and Google, qualify callers by telephone, complete human intake and coordinate the claimant’s signature on your firm’s own representation agreement. There is no separate media bill for a standard engagement; your proposal states the price, billable event, payment schedule and review window.
What counts as a signed case?
The words “pay per signed case” do not settle when money is due. Read the billable event in the contract, because these are different promises.
| Billable event | You pay when | What to check |
|---|---|---|
| Signature | The claimant signs your retainer | Whose agreement, what signing record and whether you can decline the file |
| Delivery | The signed file reaches you | Whether payment is due before your review ends |
| Acceptance | Your firm accepts the matter | How long you have to decide, and how a decline is recorded |
| Prepayment | Before delivery, against a future order | Order minimums, credits and what happens to undelivered cases |
Where is paying per signed case allowed?
It depends on the state, and the authorities below are a starting point for your ethics counsel, not legal advice. Our ethics guide covers 16 states in more detail.
| Position | States | What the authorities say |
|---|---|---|
| Allowed under conditions | Illinois | Rule 7.2(c), effective July 1, 2025, allows a reasonable fee for each connection that results in a hire if it is not based on the outcome or a share of fees, the service does not recommend the lawyer, and the lawyer discloses the relationship and completes due diligence. |
| Referral fees allowed | Arizona | Arizona allows referral fees. |
| Treated as a prohibited payment | Florida, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Michigan, Tennessee, Missouri, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Louisiana | Bar opinions, court decisions or statutes treat paying for a client who signs or is retained as a prohibited referral payment or a crime. |
| Barred with exceptions | Colorado | Since August 12, 2026, C.R.S. § 6-1-741 bars per-lead and per-case lead sales to Colorado lawyers unless the marketer is a lawyer, works for a clearly identified lawyer or firm, or is a nonprofit legal services organization. |
| Runner, capper and barratry laws apply | Texas, California, Georgia | These states have statutes that reach paid solicitation, several tightened in 2025 and 2026. Review contact methods as well as the fee. |
What does CaseLead use where per-case fees are restricted?
We sell in those states under agreements built for their rules, and we quote them per proposal. Depending on the state, the structure can be one of the following. Your ethics counsel should review whichever one is proposed.
- A flat program fee that does not vary with how many clients sign
- A per-lead fee that is never tied to whether a client is retained
- Firm-branded advertising, where your firm is identified as the advertiser
- In Colorado, marketing for a clearly identified lawyer or firm
Is paying per signed case cheaper than buying leads?
Work it out on your own numbers. Divide the price of a lead by your sign rate to get a media-only cost per signed case, then add the intake labor those leads consume. For example, a $500 exclusive lead at a 20% sign rate costs $2,500 per signed case before labor, while the same lead at 10% costs $5,000. These are illustrative figures, not benchmarks.
A fixed price per retainer removes the sign-rate risk, and leads keep it with you. If your intake already signs a high share of the leads you buy, leads can cost less. If your sign rate is low or unmeasured, a fixed price is easier to budget. Our calculator compares the two on your inputs.
Questions law firms ask
What companies offer pay-per-signed-case marketing for personal injury firms?
CaseLead Agency offers it at $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer where state rules allow, and a different structure elsewhere. Our provider comparison lists other companies that describe signed-retainer pricing on their websites.
Is pay per signed case legal?
Not everywhere. Illinois allows a reasonable per-hire connecting fee under conditions and Arizona allows referral fees, while authorities in states including Florida, New Jersey and New York treat a fee tied to a signed client as a referral payment. Ask your ethics counsel about your state.
Does the firm pay for ad spend on top?
Not with CaseLead’s standard signed MVA engagement, which has no separate media bill. Check this with any provider, since some bill media separately.
Can I decline a signed case and not pay?
Your firm always decides whether to accept a case. Whether a declined file is charged, credited or replaced depends on the review terms in your agreement, so settle that before the first delivery.
Ask which structure fits your state.
Tell us your states and case criteria. We’ll send a written proposal with the structure, price, billable event and review terms for your ethics counsel to read.
Discuss your state