Vendor comparison

CaseLead Agency vs First Intent Leads

Both describe signed MVA retainer programs. First Intent now directs buyers to a market quote, while CaseLead publishes a standard range and sets payment terms in each proposal. CaseLead Agency charges $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer. On price, the First Intent Leads website says: State and market rates are quoted by phone and confirmed in writing. Checked November 17, 2026; earlier dollar tiers are not verified current quotes. CaseLead publishes this comparison and has a commercial interest, so check both vendors’ terms in writing.

How do CaseLead Agency and First Intent Leads compare?

Both describe signed MVA retainer programs. First Intent now directs buyers to a market quote, while CaseLead publishes a standard range and sets payment terms in each proposal. The First Intent Leads column comes from its own website, checked November 3, 2026. CaseLead Agency publishes this page, and its column comes from its own service pages.

QuestionCaseLead AgencyFirst Intent Leads
What it sellsA signed retainer on your agreement, or a screened inquiry, set per engagementExclusive MVA web leads, inbound calls, warm transfers and signed retainers
Price$2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer; commercial and catastrophic cases quoted separatelyState and market rates are quoted by phone and confirmed in writing. Checked November 17, 2026; earlier dollar tiers are not verified current quotes.
First order and termSet in the written proposalRequest the minimum, deposit, review deadline and remedy for the specific program. Its public pricing overview directs buyers to a market quote.
If a file failsReview window and any credit or replacement terms written into each agreementSigned cases have a 14-day review window with replacement or credit, though its homepage also advertises a seven-day review. Bad numbers and spam are replaced, and transfers that miss your criteria are replaced at no cost.
Who screens claimantsPeople on our team qualify callers by telephone and complete human intakeFault, injury and representation are cleared, and injury is confirmed in a live conversation, for signed and transfer products.
Case typesAuto, truck and commercial, rideshare, motorcycle, pedestrian and slip-and-fall mattersSells commercial vehicle signed cases and names truck leads; rideshare is not published.
StatesAgreed per engagement; the proposal confirms availability and the structure your state’s rules allowConfirm state availability for the selected program in the current written quote. Earlier program-specific exclusions were not reverified November 17.

When might First Intent Leads be the better choice?

Be honest about what you need. First Intent Leads may be the better fit if:

  • You want a market-specific written quote for the selected program
  • You want to ask whether a pay-when-you-sign program is available in your market
  • You need written pricing and criteria for recent-accident matters

When might CaseLead Agency be the better choice?

CaseLead may be the better fit if:

  • You do not want to prepay half of a 10-case order, subject to your proposal
  • You need California or Colorado, where some of its products are not offered

What can this comparison not tell you?

It cannot tell you which vendor will perform better for your firm. We have not used First Intent Leads or tested its fulfillment, and CaseLead publishes this page. CaseLead does not publish a volume guarantee, and we know of no independent reviews of CaseLead yet, so ask us for what you would ask First Intent Leads: the ads, the intake script, the billable event and the review terms, in writing.

How can you test First Intent Leads against CaseLead?

Give both vendors the same written criteria for the same state, take the smallest order each allows, and track every file from delivery to your decision. Compare total cost per case your firm accepts, including your own staff time, not the list price.

Questions law firms ask

Is CaseLead Agency or First Intent Leads better?

It depends on what you want delivered. Both describe signed MVA retainer programs. First Intent now directs buyers to a market quote, while CaseLead publishes a standard range and sets payment terms in each proposal.

Is CaseLead Agency cheaper than First Intent Leads?

CaseLead charges $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer. On price, the First Intent Leads website says: State and market rates are quoted by phone and confirmed in writing. Checked November 17, 2026; earlier dollar tiers are not verified current quotes. Compare total cost per case your firm accepts.

What does First Intent Leads sell?

First Intent Leads sells exclusive MVA web leads, inbound calls, warm transfers and signed retainers.

Sources and further reading

Your firm's acquisition brief

Compare CaseLead with your shortlist.

Tell us your states, case criteria and review capacity. We will put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can set beside any other vendor’s.

Discuss signed MVA cases