Original research

How do AI assistants decide which car accident lawyer to recommend?

When we asked four AI assistants for the best car accident lawyer in 25 U.S. cities on November 13, 2026, they leaned on lawyer directories and ranking sites more than on law firms’ own websites. Super Lawyers was cited in 55 of 100 answers, including all 25 Gemini answers; Avvo in 38, including 22 of 25 ChatGPT answers; Expertise.com in 31; and Forbes Advisor’s city rankings in 23, almost all from Perplexity. ChatGPT cited a law firm’s own site in only 6 of 25 answers, while Gemini and Perplexity cited firm sites in every answer. Google AI Mode cited Google’s own search and Maps pages in 19 of 25. For a personal injury firm, that makes directory profiles, peer ratings, editorial rankings and a Google Business Profile part of being recommended by AI, alongside the firm’s own city pages.

How we ran the study

We sent the same question, “Who is the best car accident lawyer in [city]?”, to ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Mode for 25 cities: Houston, Dallas, San Antonio, Austin, Los Angeles, San Diego, Sacramento, Phoenix, Las Vegas, Atlanta, Miami, Orlando, Tampa, Jacksonville, Chicago, New York City, Philadelphia, Denver, Seattle, Charlotte, Nashville, St. Louis, New Orleans, Columbus and Detroit. That gave 100 answers. For each, we recorded every web page the assistant cited and grouped them by website.

The sources AI assistants cite most

Number of answers, out of 25 per engine, that cited each website at least once.

SourceChatGPTGeminiPerplexityGoogle AI ModeAll engines
Super Lawyers1 of 2525 of 2519 of 2510 of 2555 of 100
Avvo22 of 257 of 259 of 25038 of 100
Expertise.com19 of 25012 of 25031 of 100
Google’s own search and Maps pages4 of 250019 of 2523 of 100
Forbes Advisor03 of 2520 of 25023 of 100
Justia014 of 258 of 25022 of 100
BestinHood2 of 2509 of 25011 of 100
OnTopList009 of 2509 of 100
Law Leaderboard8 of 250008 of 100
Ben Crump Law (firm site)08 of 25008 of 100
Best Law Firms08 of 25008 of 100
Attorney at Law Magazine07 of 25007 of 100
LawInfo01 of 256 of 2507 of 100
Best Lawyers List4 of 25001 of 255 of 100

Each assistant works differently

The engines differ in how many sources they cite and which kinds. A firm that shows up in one may be invisible in another.

EngineSites cited per answerAnswers citing a directory or rankingAnswers citing a firm’s own siteMost-cited source
ChatGPT3.224 of 256 of 25Avvo (22 of 25)
Gemini6.425 of 2525 of 25Super Lawyers (25 of 25)
Perplexity9.225 of 2525 of 25Forbes Advisor (20 of 25)
Google AI Mode1.615 of 255 of 25Google’s own search and Maps pages (19 of 25)

ChatGPT: directory profiles first

ChatGPT cited 3.2 websites per answer on average, and 24 of 25 answers cited a directory or ranking site. Avvo appeared in 22 answers and Expertise.com in 19; a law firm’s own site appeared in only 6. For ChatGPT, a complete Avvo profile with reviews, and inclusion in editorial lists such as Expertise.com, matter more than anything on the firm’s website.

Gemini: Super Lawyers in every answer

Gemini cited Super Lawyers in all 25 answers and Justia in 14, and it also cited firm websites in every answer, 6.4 sites per answer on average. Super Lawyers says it selects about 5% of attorneys, that attorneys do not pay to be published and that it keeps research and advertising separate; it sells premium profiles and online advertising to lawyers.

Perplexity: editorial city rankings

Perplexity cited the most sources, 9.2 per answer. Forbes Advisor’s city pages, such as its best car accident lawyers in Austin, Philadelphia and New York City, appeared in 20 of 25 answers, with Super Lawyers in 19 and Expertise.com in 12. Editorial rankings carry weight here, and so do firm sites, which appeared in every answer.

Google AI Mode: Google’s own pages

Google AI Mode cited the fewest sources, 1.6 per answer, and 19 of 25 answers cited Google’s own search results or Maps listings. That points to the Google Business Profile, its reviews and its categories as the main lever for Google’s AI answers, with Super Lawyers (10 answers) and Thumbtack (5) behind it.

Which firm websites get cited

Firm websites were cited mostly by Gemini and Perplexity. The most-cited firm across cities was Ben Crump Law, in 8 answers, through city pages such as its Austin car accident lawyer page. A firm that serves several cities gets cited for each city it has a specific page for; a single generic practice page gets cited less.

What a personal injury firm can do

These are the levers the data points to, in rough order of reach across the four assistants. Check your state’s advertising rules before you pay for any listing or rating.

  • Claim and complete your Avvo profile and ask satisfied clients for reviews there (ChatGPT)
  • Keep your Super Lawyers profile current if you are selected, and your Justia profile complete (Gemini, Perplexity)
  • Find out how editorial lists such as Expertise.com and Forbes Advisor choose firms, and make sure your public information supports inclusion (ChatGPT, Perplexity)
  • Keep your Google Business Profile accurate, in the right category, with recent reviews (Google AI Mode)
  • Publish a specific page for each city you serve, with real facts about the practice there (Gemini, Perplexity)
  • Re-run the question for your own city every quarter, since answers change

Where CaseLead fits

AI visibility builds over months. CaseLead Agency, which ran this study, sells clients now: it runs its own advertising, qualifies callers by telephone, completes human intake and coordinates the signature on your firm’s retainer, at $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer.

Questions law firms ask

How does ChatGPT decide which lawyer to recommend?

In our 25-city test, ChatGPT relied mostly on directory and ranking sites: Avvo appeared in 22 of 25 answers and Expertise.com in 19, while firm websites appeared in only 6.

Do AI assistants use Super Lawyers?

Heavily. Super Lawyers was cited in 55 of 100 answers, including every Gemini answer and 19 of 25 Perplexity answers.

How can a law firm show up in Google AI Mode?

Google AI Mode cited Google’s own search and Maps pages in 19 of 25 answers, so an accurate, well-reviewed Google Business Profile is the main lever.

Does a law firm’s website matter for AI recommendations?

For Gemini and Perplexity, yes: both cited firm websites in every answer, especially city-specific pages. ChatGPT and Google AI Mode cited firm sites far less.

Can a firm pay to be recommended by AI?

Not directly. Assistants cite directories, rankings and firm pages; some directories sell profile upgrades or placements, while Super Lawyers says attorneys do not pay to be published. Check your state bar’s rules on paid ratings and listings.

Sources and further reading

Your firm's acquisition brief

Tell us which cases your firm wants.

Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.

Discuss your case criteria