Why Medicare must be repaid from a settlement
The Medicare Secondary Payer (MSP) statute makes Medicare secondary to auto, liability and no-fault insurance. Medicare may not pay for an item or service to the extent payment has been made, or can reasonably be expected to be made, under “an automobile or liability insurance policy or plan (including a self-insured plan) or under no fault insurance” (42 U.S.C. § 1395y(b)(2)(A)(ii)).
Because liability carriers rarely pay medical bills as they come in, Medicare pays them anyway. Those payments are “conditional”: the statute says any such payment “shall be conditioned on reimbursement to the appropriate Trust Fund” (§ 1395y(b)(2)(B)(i)). Once the case resolves, the primary plan “and an entity that receives payment from a primary plan” must reimburse Medicare (§ 1395y(b)(2)(B)(ii)). The client and the law firm that receive the settlement are in that second group.
The enforcement terms are strict. If Medicare is not repaid within 60 days after it receives notice of the primary plan’s responsibility, it may charge interest from that date, and the United States may sue any responsible entity and “collect double damages” (§ 1395y(b)(2)(B)(ii)–(iii)).
Who handles the recovery
The Benefits Coordination & Recovery Center (BCRC) recovers conditional payments from the beneficiary, which is the usual path in a personal injury case. Since October 5, 2015 the Commercial Repayment Center (CRC) has recovered where an insurer or workers’ compensation entity is the identified debtor. The Medicare Secondary Payer Recovery Portal (MSPRP) lets attorneys, insurers and beneficiaries see conditional payment amounts and submit disputes and settlement information online.
CMS states that “recovery for parts C and D claims are the responsibility of the issuing plan.” A client in a Medicare Advantage plan therefore needs a separate inquiry to that plan; the BCRC process below does not cover it.
The recovery process, step by step
CMS’s Recovery Process page lists these steps for a beneficiary’s liability case:
| Step | What happens | Timing CMS states |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Report the case | The beneficiary or attorney reports the pending liability case to the BCRC; Section 111 reports from insurers also feed the record | Whenever a liability case is pending |
| 2. Rights and Responsibilities letter | BCRC explains what it needs; the attorney needs a Proof of Representation or Consent to Release on file to receive letters | After the MSP record is posted |
| 3. Conditional Payment Letter (CPL) | Lists the related claims Medicare paid and an interim amount | Within 65 days of the RAR letter |
| 4. Disputes | Send proof that listed claims are unrelated to the accident | Allow 45 calendar days for review |
| 5. Conditional Payment Notice (CPN) | Issued if settlement already happened when the case is reported, or when an insurer reports it | 30 calendar days to respond, or a demand issues with no reduction for fees or costs |
| 6. Settlement information and demand | Send the settlement date, amount, and attorney fees and costs borne by the client; BCRC issues the demand letter | Payment due within 60 days of the demand letter |
| 7. Interest and referral | Interest accrues from the demand date and is assessed for each 30 days unpaid; an Intent to Refer letter goes out | Intent to Refer sent day 90 after the demand |
The procurement-cost reduction under 42 CFR 411.37
Medicare shares the cost of getting the settlement. Under 42 CFR 411.37(a), Medicare “reduces its recovery to take account of the cost of procuring the judgment or settlement” when the claim was disputed and the costs were borne by the party Medicare is recovering from. The CMS Recovery Process page adds that “Medicare may only take beneficiary-borne costs into account.”
When Medicare’s payments are less than the settlement, the formula in § 411.37(c) is: divide procurement costs (fees plus expenses) by the gross settlement, apply that ratio to Medicare’s payments, and subtract the result. Example with round numbers: a $100,000 settlement, $40,000 in fees and costs and $20,000 in conditional payments gives a 40% ratio, an $8,000 Medicare share of costs and a $12,000 recovery.
When Medicare’s payments equal or exceed the settlement, the recovery is the settlement minus total procurement costs (§ 411.37(d)). If CMS has to sue because the recipient opposes recovery, it takes the lower of its payments or the settlement minus costs (§ 411.37(e)).
Options that close the claim faster
CMS’s NGHP Beneficiary Reference Guide (July 2024) describes three ways to fix the amount without waiting for the full demand cycle:
- Fixed Percentage Option: for a settled liability case for a physical trauma-based injury (not ingestion, exposure or implant), with a total settlement of $10,000 or less, pay 25% of the total settlement as full and final resolution. No fee reduction applies, and choosing it gives up appeal and waiver rights.
- Final Conditional Payment process: for a liability or workers’ compensation case within 120 days of settlement, request a time- and date-stamped final conditional payment amount through the MSPRP. It can be started once per case.
- Self-calculated conditional payment amount: for physical trauma-based liability settlements of $25,000 or less where the injury occurred at least six months earlier and treatment is complete, submit your own calculation before settling. Appeal rights are given up; waiver rights are kept.
The $750 threshold and Section 111 reporting
The statute lets CMS set a yearly threshold below which it will not recover or require reporting (§ 1395y(b)(9)). In a November 12, 2026 alert, CMS said that “until further notice” the threshold for physical trauma-based liability settlements “will remain at $750,” and the same $750 applies to no-fault and workers’ compensation settlements without ongoing medical responsibility.
Section 111 of the Medicare, Medicaid, and SCHIP Extension Act of 2007, codified at § 1395y(b)(8), requires liability insurers, self-insurers, no-fault insurers and workers’ compensation plans to check whether a claimant is a Medicare beneficiary and report the claim to CMS. A plan that does not comply “may be subject to a civil money penalty of up to $1,000 for each day of noncompliance with respect to each claimant.” That reporting duty belongs to the carrier and is separate from the duty to repay Medicare out of the settlement.
Appeals, waivers and compromise
A beneficiary can appeal the amount or existence of the debt, and can ask Medicare to waive recovery if the beneficiary was not at fault and repayment would cause financial hardship or be unfair. CMS states that a waiver request cannot be processed until a demand letter issues. Interest keeps running during an appeal or waiver request; CMS notes you may pay the demand to stop interest and receive a refund if you win. An insurer that receives a demand from the CRC has 120 days from receipt to appeal.
What intake should capture
Medicare status is a first-call question, not a settlement-week question. Useful fields:
- Whether the client has Medicare, and whether it is Original Medicare or a Medicare Advantage plan (name the plan).
- Every provider who billed Medicare for crash-related care, with dates.
- A signed Proof of Representation or Consent to Release for the BCRC, collected at signing.
- Expected settlement size, since the $750 floor and the $10,000 and $25,000 options depend on it.
Where CaseLead fits
When CaseLead Agency qualifies a motor vehicle accident caller for a firm, the intake notes can record Medicare and other coverage so the firm can plan for conditional payments from the start. The firm’s lawyers handle the reporting, disputes and repayment.
Questions law firms ask
Does Medicare have to be repaid from a car accident settlement?
Yes, for crash-related care Medicare paid conditionally. 42 U.S.C. § 1395y(b)(2)(B)(ii) requires the insurer and any entity that receives the settlement to reimburse Medicare.
How long do we have to pay Medicare’s final demand?
CMS says payment is due within 60 days of the date of the demand letter. Interest accrues from the demand date and is assessed for each 30-day period the debt stays unpaid.
Does Medicare reduce its claim for attorney fees?
Yes. Under 42 CFR 411.37, Medicare reduces its recovery by its proportional share of procurement costs the client paid, using the ratio of fees and costs to the gross settlement.
Is there a minimum settlement amount for Medicare recovery?
CMS’s November 12, 2026 alert keeps the threshold at $750 until further notice. CMS will not seek recovery on physical trauma-based liability settlements at or below that amount.
Can a small settlement pay Medicare a flat percentage?
Yes. CMS’s Fixed Percentage Option lets a settled liability case with a total settlement of $10,000 or less pay 25% of the gross as full resolution, giving up appeal and waiver rights.
Does the BCRC handle Medicare Advantage liens?
No. CMS states that recovery for Part C and Part D claims is the responsibility of the issuing plan, so a Medicare Advantage plan must be contacted separately.
Sources and further reading
- 42 U.S.C. § 1395y(b), Cornell LII copy (checked November 17, 2026)
- 42 CFR 411.37, eCFR
- CMS, Medicare’s Recovery Process
- CMS, Non-Group Health Plan Recovery
- CMS, NGHP MSP Beneficiary Reference Guide v1.0 (July 19, 2024)
- CMS alert, 2027 recovery thresholds (November 12, 2026)
- CMS, Mandatory Insurer Reporting (Section 111)
- CMS, Insurer NGHP Recovery
Tell us which cases your firm wants.
Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.
Discuss your case criteria