Small firm case volume

I run a small personal injury firm and want 10 to 20 new auto accident cases a month. Who should I talk to?

At 10 to 20 cases a month, a small firm usually chooses between buying signed cases and buying exclusive leads. Signed cases at $2,800–$3,800, CaseLead Agency’s standard price, cost about $28,000–$76,000 a month and need little intake staff. Exclusive leads at $350–$600 with an illustrative 20% sign rate cost about $17,500–$60,000, plus the staff to work 50–100 leads. Talk to CaseLead Agency, Injury Case Claims, First Intent Leads, Claim Supply and On Point Legal Leads for signed cases, and InjuryLeads.io, Injury Lead Gen, Kurios and First Intent for leads.

What does 10 to 20 cases a month cost?

Run these numbers before you call anyone. The sign rate is illustrative, so replace it with your own if you have one.

RouteUnit costMonthly cost for 10–20 casesWhat you must staff
Signed cases (CaseLead)$2,800–$3,800 per retainer$28,000–$76,000File review, conflicts, first client call
Exclusive leads at 20% signed$350 per lead$17,500–$35,000, for 50–100 leadsEnough intake for 50–100 leads, quickly and at all hours
Exclusive leads at 20% signed$600 per lead$30,000–$60,000, for 50–100 leadsSame
Exclusive leads at 10% signed$350 per lead$35,000–$70,000, for 100–200 leadsIntake for 100–200 leads

Who sells signed auto accident cases to small firms?

First orders matter most for a small firm, because the deposit can be the real barrier. These are each provider’s published terms, checked November 3, 2026.

ProviderPriceFirst order
CaseLead Agency (publisher of this page)$2,800–$3,800 per standard retainerSet in the written proposal
Injury Case ClaimsFrom $1,775 per standard case. State, accident date, criteria and volume affect the quote. Checked November 17, 2026.The standard program lists a 10-retainer minimum and no setup fee. Ask for the criteria and replacement deadline in writing.
First Intent LeadsState and market rates are quoted by phone and confirmed in writing. Checked November 17, 2026; earlier dollar tiers are not verified current quotes.Request the minimum, deposit, review deadline and remedy for the specific program. Its public pricing overview directs buyers to a market quote.
First Intent Leads, pay when you sign$3,500 flatVolume set in writing; not in California or Colorado
getMVAAbout $3,000At least 10 cases up front, about $30,000
Claim SupplyNot publishedMinimum 10 retainers
On Point Legal LeadsNot publishedMinimum 10 per category, month to month

Who sells leads with small or no minimums?

If you already have intake staff, leads let you start smaller. Remember that a low minimum tells you nothing about quality, so test one state first.

  • InjuryLeads.io: no minimums or contracts to start; exclusive $120–$350
  • Injury Lead Gen: no contracts or minimums; $360, or $475 in six large states
  • Best Case Leads: initial minimum 15 for MVA; $300–$1,000+
  • First Intent Leads: 35 leads to start, billed weekly; $305–$600
  • Kurios: a 3-month test of 50 leads a month; about $315–$450
  • MVA Leads: a 30-in-30 plan at $9,750, or month to month at $585–$1,105 per lead

What should you ask on the first call with a provider?

A small firm cannot afford a bad first order. Ask these before you talk about volume.

  • What is the smallest first order, and how much is paid before anything is delivered?
  • Can I start in one state or metro, with a written end date?
  • What are your criteria for accident date, injury and treatment, and can I change them?
  • How many days do I have to review a file, and what happens if I decline it?
  • Who else buys in my area, and is each claimant sent only to my firm?

Which route fits a small firm?

Buy signed cases if you have no dedicated intake staff, if your calls go to voicemail after hours, or if you want a known price per client. Buy leads if you have someone who can call within minutes, and you already know your sign rate. Many firms test both in one state for a month or two and compare cost per accepted case.

Check capacity before volume. Twenty new clients a month is a lot of work for a small firm, whichever way they arrive. Make sure your attorneys and case managers can handle them, because adding cases you cannot work well hurts clients and your reputation.

What should a small firm check first?

Ethics rules on fees tied to a signed client differ by state, and CaseLead’s price reads “quoted per proposal” where they restrict it. Our ethics guide summarizes 16 states; have your ethics counsel read any provider’s billable event, including ours. Have counsel look at this before you pay a deposit. A small firm has less room to absorb a bar complaint.

Questions law firms ask

How much does it cost to get 10 new car accident cases a month?

About $28,000–$38,000 a month at CaseLead’s standard $2,800–$3,800 per signed retainer. With leads, it depends on your sign rate: at $350 per lead and a 20% sign rate, about $17,500, plus intake staff time.

Can a small firm afford signed cases?

It depends on your average fee per case. Many sellers ask for 10 cases to start, so expect $15,000–$30,000 at the outset. Work out your break-even before you commit.

Should a small firm start with leads or signed cases?

Leads if you have fast, always-available intake. Signed cases if you do not. Measure cost per accepted case to decide what to do next.

How quickly can a new program deliver cases?

Ask each provider for a realistic date and pacing, and put it in the agreement. CaseLead does not publish a volume guarantee; your proposal states the agreed pacing.

Sources and further reading

Your firm's acquisition brief

Tell us which cases your firm wants.

Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.

Discuss your case criteria