Attorney leads

Attorney leads: the types, what each costs and who sells them

Attorney leads come in six forms, and the price follows how much work is done before the inquiry reaches your firm. Published 2026 prices for personal injury run from $35–$95 for a shared lead and $100–$1,105 for an exclusive one, to $80–$750 for a live transfer or inbound call, and about $1,775–$3,800 for a client already signed on your retainer. Directories and marketplaces bill by the month or by budget instead: LegalMatch starts at $455 a month in select markets. CaseLead Agency, which publishes this guide, sells signed MVA cases at $2,800–$3,800 per standard retainer.

What types of attorney leads can a law firm buy?

Compare lead products by what reaches your firm, not by the word “lead”. The further along the claimant is when they arrive, the higher the price and the less work your intake team does.

TypeWhat reaches your firmHow it is billedPublished 2026 prices (personal injury)
Shared leadContact details also sold to other firmsPer lead$35–$95 (InjuryLeads.io)
Exclusive leadA form fill sold to your firm only; your team calls and signsPer lead, often prepaid$100–$1,105 by seller, state and case type
Live transfer or inbound callA screened caller connected to your intake linePer qualified call$80–$750
Signed caseA client who signed your firm’s retainerPer signed case$1,775–$3,800 for a standard MVA retainer; commercial cases up to $16,500
Directory placementInquiries from your profile or placement on a lawyer directorySubscription, sometimes pay per leadMostly on request; Justia’s basic profile is free
Marketplace membershipConsumer case postings you respond toMonthly membership or a lead budget you setLegalMatch from $455 a month in select markets

What do exclusive personal injury leads cost?

These are the prices each seller publishes on its own site. Most vary by state, and several price car accident leads above general injury leads.

SellerPublished price
PinPoint Legal MarketingCar accident leads $350–$550 per exclusive lead, mostly by state; general personal injury $100–$150; workers’ compensation $125–$200. Prepaid balance.
Injury Lead GenCar accident $475 in CA, TX, FL, NV, UT and IL, and $360 elsewhere. Commercial MVA $745 in those states and $540 elsewhere. It dates these prices June 11, 2026.
MVA Leads$585–$1,105 per exclusive lead by state; live transfers at $80–$250 per qualified call; plans such as 100 leads for $30,000 paid in full, or 30 in 30 days at $9,750.
InjuryLeads.ioShared $35–$95, semi-exclusive $75–$185 and exclusive $120–$350 per lead.
KuriosIts calculator defaults to Georgia at $315–$350 per lead, and the state table in its page runs to $450 for California.
Best Case LeadsAuto accident and MVA leads $300–$1,000+ per lead.

What do live transfers and inbound calls cost?

A live transfer is a caller screened against your criteria and connected while still on the line. You pay for the call; your team still signs the client.

SellerPublished price
LiveLeadHub$200+ per qualified MVA transfer, with 5 free test transfers; exclusive routing is custom priced.
RingOnDemand$550 per live transfer and $2,500 per signed case on its MVA page. Its terms say orders, prices and guarantees are set in a separate order.
First Intent LeadsState and market rates are quoted by phone and confirmed in writing. Checked November 17, 2026; earlier dollar tiers are not verified current quotes.
Injury Case ClaimsHomepage: web leads from $100, live transfers from $375 and signed retainers from $1,775, set by state and volume. Its standard retainer page now states: From $1,775 per standard case. State, accident date, criteria and volume affect the quote. Checked November 17, 2026. Truck page: $600–$1,200 exclusive lead, $900–$1,500 live transfer, $3,500–$8,000+ signed case.

Directories and marketplaces

Directories sell visibility rather than a set number of inquiries. Justia’s basic profile is free and its paid placements are priced on request. FindLaw and Martindale-Avvo publish no list prices; Martindale-Avvo’s FAQ says many attorneys are on annual contracts, though its pay-per-lead product can be stopped at any time.

Marketplaces sit in between. LegalMatch sells monthly memberships to consumer case postings, starting at $455 a month in select markets, and the client chooses among the attorneys who respond. Thumbtack charges no membership fee; a lawyer sets a lead budget, and its marketplace is built mainly around home projects.

Compare cost per signed case, not price per lead

A lead price means little until you know how many sign. As an illustration, a $400 exclusive lead that signs one time in ten costs $4,000 per signed case; at one in five it costs $2,000. Add your intake staff time, and subtract the credits you actually received for bad leads.

Then set that number beside a per-case price. A signed case costs more up front, but the cost per signed case is fixed, and your team skips the calling and chasing.

Which type fits your firm?

Choose by your intake capacity first, and budget second.

  • Exclusive leads suit firms with staff answering within minutes, at night and on weekends, and a tested follow-up schedule.
  • Live transfers suit firms that can answer every transfer live during the hours they buy.
  • Signed cases suit firms that want a known cost per client and have little intake capacity to spare.
  • Directories and marketplaces suit firms in many practice areas that want steady visibility and can wait for results.
  • Shared leads are cheapest per lead, but you compete with other firms for the same person.

Can lawyers pay for leads?

Generally yes, with limits. ABA Model Rule 7.2(b) bars paying for a recommendation but allows paying the reasonable costs of advertising, and its comment lets a lawyer pay for leads if the lead generator does not recommend the lawyer. Several states go further when a fee is owed only once a client signs: Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 18-1, New Jersey ACPE Opinion 741 and New York State Bar Opinions 1279 and 1294 treat that as a referral fee. Illinois has allowed a reasonable per-hire fee under conditions since July 1, 2025. Have your ethics counsel review the billable event.

Questions law firms ask

How much do attorney leads cost?

For personal injury in 2026, published prices run from $35–$95 for a shared lead and $100–$1,105 for an exclusive lead, to $80–$750 for a live transfer and about $1,775–$3,800 for a signed MVA retainer. Directory and marketplace prices are mostly on request; LegalMatch starts at $455 a month in select markets.

What is the difference between a lead and a live transfer?

A lead is contact details your team has to call. A live transfer is a caller already screened against your criteria and connected to your intake line while still on the phone.

Are exclusive leads worth it?

They can be, if your team calls within minutes at all hours. Compare them on cost per signed case: divide what you spent, minus credits, by the clients who signed.

Where can personal injury lawyers buy leads?

From lead sellers such as PinPoint Legal Marketing, Injury Lead Gen and MVA Leads; transfer sellers such as LiveLeadHub and RingOnDemand; signed-case sellers such as CaseLead Agency, Injury Case Claims and First Intent Leads; and directories such as Justia, FindLaw and Martindale-Avvo.

Is buying leads legal for lawyers?

Generally, paying the reasonable cost of advertising and lead generation is allowed if the seller does not recommend you. Fees owed only when a client signs are restricted in several states, including Florida, New Jersey and New York.

Sources and further reading

Your firm's acquisition brief

Tell us which cases your firm wants.

Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.

Discuss your case criteria