ABA Model Rule 7.2

Does ABA Model Rule 7.2 let lawyers pay for leads?

Yes, with limits. Rule 7.2(b) bars a lawyer from giving anything of value for recommending the lawyer’s services, but it lets a lawyer pay the reasonable costs of advertising. Comment [5] adds that a lawyer may pay for client leads if the lead generator does not recommend the lawyer, the payment is consistent with Rules 1.5(e) and 5.4, and its communications are consistent with Rule 7.1. Each state adopts its own version, and several go further on fees tied to a signed client. This is general information, not legal advice.

What does Rule 7.2(b) say?

The general rule is that a lawyer may not pay for a recommendation. The rule then lists exceptions. These are the ones that matter most when buying leads.

ExceptionWhat it allows
7.2(b)(1)Paying the reasonable costs of advertisements and communications the rule permits
7.2(b)(2)Paying the usual charges of a legal service plan, or of a not-for-profit or qualified lawyer referral service
7.2(b)(3)Paying for a law practice under Rule 1.17
7.2(b)(4)A non-exclusive reciprocal referral agreement, if the client is told about it
7.2(b)(5)Nominal gifts that are neither intended nor expected to be compensation for a recommendation

What counts as a recommendation?

Comment [2] says a communication contains a recommendation if it endorses or vouches for a lawyer’s credentials, abilities, competence, character or other professional qualities. Directory listings and group ads that list lawyers by practice area, without more, are not impermissible recommendations. Comment [3] says a lawyer may pay for advertising and may pay employees, agents and vendors who provide marketing or client-development services.

When may a lawyer pay a lead generator?

Comment [5] sets the test for lead generators, and it is the passage to read closely. It has three conditions.

  • The lead generator does not recommend the lawyer
  • Any payment is consistent with Rule 1.5(e) on dividing fees and Rule 5.4 on the lawyer’s professional independence
  • The lead generator’s communications are consistent with Rule 7.1 on truthful communications
  • Under Rule 7.1, the lawyer must not pay a generator that states or implies it is recommending the lawyer
  • Nor one that implies it is making the referral without payment from the lawyer
  • Nor one that implies it has analyzed the person’s legal problem to choose the lawyer

Does Rule 7.2 allow paying per signed case?

The Model Rule does not set out a fee structure, so the answer comes from how each state reads its own rule. A fee that depends on a client signing can look less like the cost of advertising and more like payment for a recommendation or a share of the fee.

New York State Bar Opinion 1294 (March 2026) says a lawyer’s payment to a lead generator must not change based on whether a client is retained or on the size of any fee. New Jersey Opinion 741 warns that purported leads may be disguised referrals. In Columbus Bar Assn. v. Cable (2026), Ohio’s Supreme Court found a Rule 7.2(b) violation where a lawyer paid marketing firms per client. Illinois went the other way in 2025, allowing a reasonable per-hire connecting fee under conditions. Our ethics guide covers 16 states.

Is a lawyer responsible for what the vendor does?

Comment [5] points to Rule 5.3, on lawyers’ duties regarding nonlawyers’ conduct, and Rule 8.4(a), on not violating the rules through someone else’s acts. So “the vendor did it” is a weak answer. Read the ads and scripts, and keep the review on file. In Cable, the court also found that the lawyer failed to supervise the companies’ nonlawyers who were representing his firm.

How should a firm apply Rule 7.2 before buying?

Start with your own state’s version of the rule and its ethics opinions, not the Model Rule. Then ask each vendor the questions below and have your ethics counsel review the answers. CaseLead Agency, which publishes this guide, charges $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer where the rules allow it, and uses other structures, quoted per proposal, where they do not.

  • Do the ads or scripts say or imply that a lawyer is the best choice, or that the service is free and neutral?
  • Does the fee change depending on whether a client signs or on the size of the fee?
  • Does anyone “evaluate” the person’s case in order to choose a lawyer?
  • Does the vendor contact people first, or buy crash reports to find them?
  • Does the arrangement make the vendor a lawyer referral service under your state’s rule?

Questions law firms ask

Can lawyers pay for leads under the ABA Model Rules?

Yes, under comment [5] to Rule 7.2, if the lead generator does not recommend the lawyer, the payment is consistent with Rules 1.5(e) and 5.4, and its communications meet Rule 7.1.

Is a lead generator the same as a lawyer referral service?

Not necessarily. Comment [6] describes a lawyer referral service as an organization that holds itself out to the public as one, and only permits paying the usual charges of a not-for-profit or qualified service. Check how your state draws this line.

Do state rules differ from the ABA Model Rule?

Yes. The Model Rules are a template, and each state adopts its own version. Illinois, New York, New Jersey, Ohio and Colorado, among others, have taken distinct positions.

Is this legal advice?

No. It is a summary for law firm buyers. Have your ethics counsel apply your own state’s rules to any specific arrangement.

Sources and further reading

Your firm's acquisition brief

Tell us which cases your firm wants.

Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.

Discuss your case criteria