How do CaseLead Agency and Claim Supply compare?
Both deliver signed MVA retainers. Claim Supply publishes its minimums and reporting windows but not its prices, while CaseLead publishes its price and sets order size and review terms in the proposal. The Claim Supply column comes from its own website, checked November 3, 2026. CaseLead Agency publishes this page, and its column comes from its own service pages.
| Question | CaseLead Agency | Claim Supply |
|---|---|---|
| What it sells | A signed retainer on your agreement, or a screened inquiry, set per engagement | Exclusive form-fill leads and signed MVA retainers |
| Price | $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer; commercial and catastrophic cases quoted separately | Not published; its quote builder asks for details first. Lead orders are prepaid at a fixed price per lead set by state. |
| First order and term | Set in the written proposal | Minimum 100 exclusive form-fill leads or 10 signed MVA retainers. Order based, with no automatic renewal. |
| If a file fails | Review window and any credit or replacement terms written into each agreement | Leads may be flagged within 72 hours, and signed retainers have a 14-day reporting window. Failed leads are replaced, not refunded in cash. |
| Who screens claimants | People on our team qualify callers by telephone and complete human intake | 24/7 English and Spanish intake for signed retainers, which are live-transferred during the process. |
| Case types | Auto, truck and commercial, rideshare, motorcycle, pedestrian and slip-and-fall matters | States its scope as MVA. Truck and rideshare appear only on a sample dashboard, so stated coverage is not published. |
| States | Agreed per engagement; the proposal confirms availability and the structure your state’s rules allow | Not published; firms name their states. |
When might Claim Supply be the better choice?
Be honest about what you need. Claim Supply may be the better fit if:
- You want clear, published reporting windows
- You need Spanish-language intake described in writing
- You prefer one fixed order with no renewal
When might CaseLead Agency be the better choice?
CaseLead may be the better fit if:
- You want a published price before the first call
- You do not want to prepay a 100-lead or 10-retainer minimum, subject to your proposal
What can this comparison not tell you?
It cannot tell you which vendor will perform better for your firm. We have not used Claim Supply or tested its fulfillment, and CaseLead publishes this page. CaseLead does not publish a volume guarantee, and we know of no independent reviews of CaseLead yet, so ask us for what you would ask Claim Supply: the ads, the intake script, the billable event and the review terms, in writing.
How can you test Claim Supply against CaseLead?
Give both vendors the same written criteria for the same state, take the smallest order each allows, and track every file from delivery to your decision. Compare total cost per case your firm accepts, including your own staff time, not the list price.
Questions law firms ask
Is CaseLead Agency or Claim Supply better?
It depends on what you want delivered. Both deliver signed MVA retainers. Claim Supply publishes its minimums and reporting windows but not its prices, while CaseLead publishes its price and sets order size and review terms in the proposal.
Is CaseLead Agency cheaper than Claim Supply?
CaseLead charges $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer. On price, the Claim Supply website says: Not published; its quote builder asks for details first. Lead orders are prepaid at a fixed price per lead set by state. Compare total cost per case your firm accepts.
What does Claim Supply sell?
Claim Supply sells exclusive form-fill leads and signed MVA retainers.
Sources and further reading
Compare CaseLead with your shortlist.
Tell us your states, case criteria and review capacity. We will put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can set beside any other vendor’s.
Discuss signed MVA cases