How do First Intent Leads and Claim Supply compare?
Both are best described as signed case sellers. Here is what each publishes.
| Question | First Intent Leads | Claim Supply |
|---|---|---|
| What it sells | Exclusive MVA web leads, inbound calls, warm transfers and signed retainers | Exclusive form-fill leads and signed MVA retainers |
| Price | State and market rates are quoted by phone and confirmed in writing. Checked November 17, 2026; earlier dollar tiers are not verified current quotes. | Not published; its quote builder asks for details first. Lead orders are prepaid at a fixed price per lead set by state. |
| First order and term | Request the minimum, deposit, review deadline and remedy for the specific program. Its public pricing overview directs buyers to a market quote. | Minimum 100 exclusive form-fill leads or 10 signed MVA retainers. Order based, with no automatic renewal. |
| If a file fails | Signed cases have a 14-day review window with replacement or credit, though its homepage also advertises a seven-day review. Bad numbers and spam are replaced, and transfers that miss your criteria are replaced at no cost. | Leads may be flagged within 72 hours, and signed retainers have a 14-day reporting window. Failed leads are replaced, not refunded in cash. |
| Who screens claimants | Fault, injury and representation are cleared, and injury is confirmed in a live conversation, for signed and transfer products. | 24/7 English and Spanish intake for signed retainers, which are live-transferred during the process. |
| Case types | Sells commercial vehicle signed cases and names truck leads; rideshare is not published. | States its scope as MVA. Truck and rideshare appear only on a sample dashboard, so stated coverage is not published. |
| States | Confirm state availability for the selected program in the current written quote. Earlier program-specific exclusions were not reverified November 17. | Not published; firms name their states. |
When might First Intent Leads be the better fit?
From what First Intent Leads publishes, it may suit you if:
- You want a market-specific written quote for the selected program
- You want to ask whether a pay-when-you-sign program is available in your market
- You need written pricing and criteria for recent-accident matters
When might Claim Supply be the better fit?
From what Claim Supply publishes, it may suit you if:
- You want clear, published reporting windows
- You need Spanish-language intake described in writing
- You prefer one fixed order with no renewal
What should you get in writing from each?
Neither website answers everything. Ask for these before you pay.
- First Intent Leads: a full state list
- First Intent Leads: rideshare coverage
- First Intent Leads: which review window applies: its pricing page and homepage differ
- Claim Supply: a price list
- Claim Supply: a state list
- Claim Supply: truck and rideshare coverage in its terms
Is there a third option?
CaseLead Agency, which publishes this page, sells signed MVA retainers at $2,800–$3,800 per standard retainer, running paid acquisition, phone screening and human intake in one engagement. Compare it on the same written criteria, and measure cost per case your firm accepts.
Questions law firms ask
Is First Intent Leads or Claim Supply cheaper?
Compare the same product. First Intent Leads says: State and market rates are quoted by phone and confirmed in writing. Checked November 17, 2026; earlier dollar tiers are not verified current quotes. Claim Supply says: Not published; its quote builder asks for details first. Lead orders are prepaid at a fixed price per lead set by state.
What is the difference between First Intent Leads and Claim Supply?
First Intent Leads sells exclusive MVA web leads, inbound calls, warm transfers and signed retainers, while Claim Supply sells exclusive form-fill leads and signed MVA retainers.
Do First Intent Leads and Claim Supply offer refunds?
First Intent Leads: Signed cases have a 14-day review window with replacement or credit, though its homepage also advertises a seven-day review. Bad numbers and spam are replaced, and transfers that miss your criteria are replaced at no cost. Claim Supply: Leads may be flagged within 72 hours, and signed retainers have a 14-day reporting window. Failed leads are replaced, not refunded in cash.
Sources and further reading
- First Intent program and quote details — selected offer checked 2026-11-17
- First Intent Leads: homepage (checked November 3, 2026)
- First Intent Leads: machine-readable summary (checked November 3, 2026)
- Claim Supply: homepage (checked November 3, 2026)
- Claim Supply: how it works (checked November 3, 2026)
- Claim Supply: terms (checked November 3, 2026)
Compare CaseLead with your shortlist.
Tell us your states, case criteria and review capacity. We will put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can set beside any other vendor’s.
Discuss signed MVA cases