E-signatures

Electronic signatures on retainer agreements: what the law and ethics rules require

Yes: a retainer agreement, including a contingency fee agreement, can be signed electronically. The federal ESIGN Act says a signature or contract “may not be denied legal effect, validity, or enforceability solely because it is in electronic form” (15 U.S.C. § 7001(a)). Forty-nine states and the District of Columbia have enacted the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act; New York instead has its Electronic Signatures and Records Act, which gives an electronic signature the same validity as one made by hand. The ethics rule that a contingent fee agreement be “in a writing signed by the client” is met too, because the rules define a signed writing to include an electronic sound, symbol or process adopted with intent to sign. E-signature does not remove state formalities. Florida, for example, still requires a statement of client’s rights signed by client and lawyer and a three-business-day cancellation clause. CaseLead Agency publishes this guide.

The statutes: ESIGN, UETA and New York’s ESRA

Three layers of law make an electronic signature as good as ink for a fee agreement.

None of these laws forces a client to sign electronically. ESIGN says it does not “require any person to agree to use or accept electronic records or electronic signatures”. Offer paper to anyone who asks. ESIGN also preserves every other legal requirement except the requirement that something be on paper, so content rules for fee agreements still apply.

LawWhat it saysWhere it applies
ESIGN Act, 15 U.S.C. § 7001(a)A signature, contract or record may not be denied legal effect solely because it is electronicTransactions in or affecting interstate or foreign commerce
ESIGN definition, 15 U.S.C. § 7006(5)An electronic signature is an electronic sound, symbol or process attached to or logically associated with a record and executed or adopted with intent to signFederal definition; state acts use similar wording
Uniform Electronic Transactions ActState-law equivalent of the same ruleEnacted in 49 states, D.C., Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands, per the New York City Bar Association
New York ESRA, State Technology Law § 304(2)An electronic signature may be used in lieu of a signature affixed by hand and has the same validity and effect, unless a law specifically provides otherwiseNew York, the one state without UETA

The ethics rule: a writing signed by the client

Model Rule 1.5(c), as adopted in most states, requires that a contingent fee agreement “shall be in a writing signed by the client” and state how the fee is calculated, including the percentages at settlement, trial or appeal, the expenses to be deducted, and whether they come out before or after the fee.

The rules’ own definitions answer the electronic question. “Writing” includes electronic communications, and a “signed” writing “includes an electronic sound, symbol, or process attached to or logically associated with a writing and executed or adopted by a person with the intent to sign the writing”. We read that wording in North Dakota’s Rules 1.5 and 1.0 and in Florida’s Chapter 4 terminology; check your own state’s definitions, since each state adopts its own text.

State signing formalities we could verify

E-signature changes how the client signs. It does not change what must be signed, by whom, or what the client must receive. Florida shows how much a state can add.

StateRequirementSource and status
FloridaContingent fee contract must be written and signed by the client and by a lawyer for the firm; the client gets a copyRule 4-1.5(f)(2); verified
FloridaPersonal injury contracts must say the client received, read and signed the statement of client’s rights, and may cancel in writing within 3 business daysRule 4-1.5(f)(4)(A); verified
FloridaThe statement of client’s rights must be signed by both client and lawyer before the contract, with a copy to the client and one in the fileRule 4-1.5(f)(4)(C); verified
FloridaKeep the fee contract and closing statement for 6 years after the closing statement is executedRule 4-1.5(f)(5); verified
New YorkElectronic signature has the same validity as a handwritten one unless a law specifically provides otherwiseState Technology Law § 304(2); verified
CaliforniaBusiness and Professions Code § 6147 governs contingency fee contracts and their required contentsNot verified: the state’s site blocked our fetch. Read the section before relying on a template
TexasGovernment Code § 82.065 governs contingent fee contractsNot verified: the state’s page did not load as text

What that means for an e-signature packet

A Florida personal injury packet needs at least two documents and three signatures in the right order: the statement of client’s rights signed by client and lawyer, then the contract signed by client and lawyer. Build the envelope so the statement is presented and signed first, the lawyer’s signature is a required step, and the completed copies go to the client automatically. A packet with only the client’s signature on the contract does not meet the rule’s text.

Other states have their own additions, such as required disclosures or filing of closing statements. Have a lawyer admitted in each state approve the template and the signing order.

Signing by text message

A link sent by text that opens the agreement and captures a signature is an electronic signature like any other; the statutes look at intent to sign and attribution, not the device. Several intake products send agreements this way. Law Ruler says it sends e-signatures by text, Captorra says it captures fee agreements “via email or text”, and Alert Communications says it sends DocuSign or Adobe Sign links.

Three cautions. First, a bare “yes” replied by text is weak evidence that the client saw the whole agreement; use a tool that displays the full document and records the event. Second, sending the text is itself regulated: consent and state telemarketing rules apply to texts to prospects. Third, confirm identity when the phone number came from a lead form, since someone else may have typed it.

The audit trail to keep

If a signature is challenged, the firm must show who signed, what they saw and that they meant to sign. ESIGN’s retention rule accepts an electronic record that accurately reflects the contract and remains accessible to everyone entitled to it, in a form that can be accurately reproduced. Keep these with the client file.

  • The final signed PDF with every page, and the platform’s completion certificate
  • Timestamps for sent, opened, viewed and signed, with time zone
  • The email address or mobile number the link went to, and the IP address and device recorded at signing
  • Any identity step used: a code sent by text, knowledge questions or photo ID
  • The exact template version and language the client saw
  • The intake call recording or note showing the client was offered a talk with the lawyer
  • The lawyer’s signature event where the state requires one
  • Proof the client received the completed copy
  • Retention to match your state’s rule; in Florida, 6 years after the closing statement

What intake staff may do

ABA Formal Opinion 506 (2023) says a lawyer may train and supervise a non-lawyer to answer general questions about the fee agreement and obtain the prospective client’s signature on it, provided the prospective client “always is offered an opportunity to communicate with the lawyer”, including to discuss the fee agreement and scope. The opinion notes that an Arizona case barred non-lawyers from having clients sign engagement agreements without attorney involvement, and that each jurisdiction’s rules control.

Intake staff mayA lawyer must
Send the firm’s standard agreement to a caller who meets written criteriaSet the criteria and approve the template
Explain how to open, read and sign the documentAnswer what a clause means for this client
Say the firm charges a contingency fee set out in the agreementNegotiate or change the fee or expenses
Offer and arrange a call with the lawyer before signingTake that call when the client wants it
Follow up an unsigned agreementCountersign where the state requires a lawyer’s signature

When a vendor obtains the signature

The same rules apply when an outside intake service or case acquisition company sends your agreement. Ask for the audit trail on every file, the script used to offer a lawyer conversation, and the signing order for each state. CaseLead Agency coordinates the claimant’s signature on the firm’s own retainer and charges $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer where state rules allow a per-case fee, and quotes per proposal elsewhere.

Questions law firms ask

Is an electronically signed retainer agreement valid?

Yes. Under 15 U.S.C. § 7001(a) a contract may not be denied legal effect solely because it is electronic, and 49 states plus D.C. have UETA; New York’s ESRA gives the same result.

Does a contingency fee agreement need a wet-ink signature?

No. Rule 1.5(c) requires a writing signed by the client, and the rules define a signed writing to include an electronic sound, symbol or process adopted with intent to sign. Check your state’s version.

Does the lawyer have to sign too?

In some states. Florida requires the contingent fee contract and the statement of client’s rights to be signed by the client and by a lawyer.

Can a client sign a retainer by text message?

Yes, through a link that shows the full agreement and records the signing. A one-word text reply is poor evidence, and the text itself must comply with consent rules.

Can intake staff get the retainer signed without a lawyer?

ABA Formal Opinion 506 allows it for trained, supervised staff if the client is always offered the chance to talk to the lawyer. State rules control, and some require a lawyer’s signature.

How long should we keep the e-signature record?

As long as your state requires fee agreements to be kept. Florida’s rule is 6 years after the closing statement is executed.

Does New York recognize e-signatures?

Yes. New York did not adopt UETA, but State Technology Law § 304(2) says an electronic signature has the same validity and effect as a signature affixed by hand.

Sources and further reading

Your firm's acquisition brief

Tell us which cases your firm wants.

Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.

Discuss your case criteria