What belongs in every signed auto accident case file?
Use this as the specification you agree with a vendor before the first delivery. If an item is missing, the file should say so rather than leave a blank.
| Item | What it should show | Why your team needs it |
|---|---|---|
| Signed retainer | Your firm’s agreement, its version, date signed | Confirms the right document was used |
| Signing record | How and when the claimant signed, and any e-signature audit trail | Answers a later challenge to the signature |
| Accident facts | Date, time, location, accident type, the parties identified | Sets the filing deadline and first liability view |
| Injury and treatment | Reported injury, first treatment date, providers named | First read on value and treatment gaps |
| Insurance | Reported carriers, policy details if known, whether a claim was opened | Directs your first letters |
| Representation | Whether another lawyer was consulted or hired | Avoids stepping into another firm’s client |
| Source and consent | Ad or channel, form language, timestamp | Your evidence if contact is ever challenged |
| Open items | What is missing or conflicting, and who follows up | Your team’s first task list |
How should a file separate reported facts from verified ones?
Most intake answers are what the claimant reported. That is useful, but it is not the same as a document someone has checked. Each material field should carry a status of reported, verified or unknown, along with the source and the date.
For example, a claimant may say a police report exists. The file should say that it was reported, not that the report was reviewed. If someone later reads the report and it disagrees with the claimant, keep both versions and date them. This stops one checked document from making a whole file look verified.
What is usually not in the file?
Do not assume these come with a signed case. Ask, and put the answer in the agreement.
- The police or crash report, as opposed to a report number or a statement that one exists
- Medical records and bills, which normally need the signed authorization and time to collect
- Verified insurance coverage and policy limits
- A conflict check, which only your firm can run
- A liability opinion or case valuation, which is your lawyers’ job
- A signed HIPAA authorization, unless your packet includes one
Should the file state the filing deadline?
It should give the accident date prominently, so your team can calculate the deadline using your state’s rule. A vendor should not state a deadline as legal advice. If the claimant is a minor, a government vehicle is involved or the accident happened in another state, flag that as an open item, because the time limits can be different and much shorter.
What should your team do when the file arrives?
Separate these steps. Receiving a file is not the same as accepting a case, and your records should show the difference.
- Acknowledge delivery and start the agreed review window
- Run conflicts and check for existing representation
- Call the client quickly, introduce your firm and confirm they understand the agreement
- Resolve the open items and order the report and records
- Record the decision as accepted, declined or pending, with a specific reason
- Send a declined file back through the agreed remedy process
What does CaseLead include in a signed-case handoff?
CaseLead Agency, which publishes this checklist, agrees the handoff with each firm before work starts. For a signed-case engagement, it can include the signed firm agreement and signing record, the intake answers, a unique matter identifier and a list of open items. Standard signed MVA retainers cost $2,800–$3,800. Our signed MVA page describes the process, and it links to an illustrative sample packet.
Questions law firms ask
Who should sign the retainer in a purchased case?
The claimant signs your firm’s own representation agreement. Ask the vendor who explains it and what that person is allowed to say, since non-lawyers should not give legal advice.
Should a signed case come with a police report?
Not necessarily. Many files only carry a report number or the claimant’s statement that one exists. Decide whether you require the report itself, and write that into the agreement.
How quickly should a law firm contact a signed client?
As soon as your team can, ideally the same day. A signed client who does not hear from the firm may not recognize it later, and that raises the chance of losing the client.
What makes a handoff file a warning sign?
Repeated wording across files, missing signing records, claimants who do not recognize your firm, and blanks with no explanation. Read our list of red flags for more.
Sources and further reading
Tell us which cases your firm wants.
Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.
Discuss your case criteria