Can a New Jersey law firm pay for leads?
RPC 7.2(c) bars giving anything of value for recommending the lawyer, except the reasonable cost of permitted advertising, RPC 1.17 sale costs, and usual charges of a not-for-profit lawyer referral service or legal service organization. RPC 7.3(d) separately bars paying anyone to recommend or secure employment. The 2021 joint opinion (CAA 47/ACPE 741) restates that lawyers may pay ‘per lead’ but not ‘per client retained,’ and says a price per lead far above ordinary market value suggests a client is being sold.
In short: no ABA Comment [5] text in the rule; pay-per-lead allowed, pay-per-client-retained barred (CAA/ACPE opinions).
What decides most questions is the billable event. A fee for advertising, or a fee per lead that is owed whether or not the person hires the firm, is treated as an advertising cost in most states. A fee owed only when a client signs looks like payment for the referral. Bar opinions in other states treat a fee owed only when a client signs as a referral fee rather than an advertising cost: Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 18-1 (2018), New Jersey ACPE Opinion 741 (2021) and New York State Bar Opinions 1279 (2025) and 1294 (2026). Illinois has allowed a reasonable per-hire connecting fee under conditions since July 1, 2025, and Arizona allows referral fees.
The New Jersey rule text on paying for recommendations
Verbatim extracts from New Jersey Rules of Professional Conduct (Rules of Court, Part 1 Appendices (RPC)), read November 13, 2026. Rules of Court database note: ‘Includes amendments effective on or before Sept. 1, 2026.’ Rule text pulled from the database’s JSON endpoint (njcourts.gov/njcourts_rules_of_court/get-term?tid=...) that the page loads. RPC 7.2 last amended July 30, 2021 (eff. Sept. 1, 2021); RPC 7.3 last amended Apr. 30, 2018.
- “A lawyer shall not give anything of value to a person for recommending the lawyer's services, except that: (1) a lawyer may pay the reasonable cost of advertising or written communication permitted by this Rule” (RPC 7.2(c): no value for recommending, exceptions)
- “A lawyer shall not compensate or give anything of value to a person or organization to recommend or secure the lawyer's employment by a client” (RPC 7.3(d))
- “The Committee on Attorney Advertising, in Opinion 43 (2011), found that lawyers may pay “per lead” but may not pay “per client retained.”” (CAA Op. 47/ACPE Op. 741 (2021): per lead OK, per client retained not)
- “Prices per lead that are significantly higher than the ordinary marketplace value of a lead suggest that the sale is of a client, not a lead.” (CAA 47: price far above market suggests sale of a client)
New Jersey runner, capper and solicitation statutes
Knowingly acting as a runner, or using, soliciting, directing, hiring or employing a runner, is a crime. A runner is a person who for pecuniary benefit procures or attempts to procure a client in cooperation with a provider (defined to include an attorney) seeking insurance benefits or asserting a claim against an insured or insurer. Procurement through public media (including mailed or electronic written communications without in-person contact) is excluded. Imprisonment is presumed on conviction.
Penalties: Crime of the third degree (2C:21-22.1(b)); court shall impose imprisonment unless it would be a serious injustice (2C:21-22.1(c)). Third-degree crime: 3 to 5 years (2C:43-6(a)(3)); fine up to $15,000 (2C:43-3(b)(1)).
For a firm buying leads or signed cases, the practical question is how the vendor reaches people: public advertising that the person answers is treated differently from an agent who approaches accident victims for the firm.
Contacting accident victims in New Jersey: waiting periods
30-day bar on unsolicited direct contact with a prospective client after a specific mass-disaster event, when the contact concerns compensation from that event. Applies to any form of contact or written/electronic communication by a lawyer. For other specific events (e.g., ordinary car crashes) there is no waiting period, but unsolicited direct contact is barred except a regular-mail letter marked ADVERTISEMENT (letter and envelope) with the required notices, including one that the recipient may report an inaccurate or misleading letter to the Committee on Attorney Advertising.
Citation: N.J. RPC 7.3(b)(4), (b)(5).
New Jersey advertising filing and records
No rule read requires filing ads or solicitation letters. Any New Jersey lawyer may ask the Committee on Attorney Advertising for an advisory opinion on an ad; an approving opinion bars ethics charges except for a charge that the ad is false or misleading under RPC 7.1(a)(1), and using a disapproved ad is per se unethical.
Keep a copy or recording of each advertisement or written communication for three years after dissemination with a record of when and where it was used; capture all website material at least monthly and retain it three years (Guideline 4 exempts approved legal assistance organizations).
| Item | New Jersey |
|---|---|
| Filing or review required | voluntary review only |
| Who reviews | Supreme Court Committee on Attorney Advertising |
| Timing | No pre-filing. Voluntary written inquiry with a copy of the ad, acted on at the next meeting if received 10 business days before it. |
| Fee | none stated in R. 1:19A-3 |
| Record retention | 3 years after dissemination; websites backed up at least monthly and kept 3 years |
| Citation | N.J. Ct. R. 1:19A-3; RPC 7.1 (last paragraph) |
Testimonials and past results in ads
Testimonials and endorsements are allowed (CAA Opinion 49, issued Sept. 30, 2025, superseding Opinions 15 and 33). Any testimonial about past performance needs the conspicuous disclaimer ‘Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances’ (also in direct mail); an actor portraying a real client requires a dramatization disclosure; comparative language is not permitted in testimonials. RPC 7.1(a)(2) bars communications likely to create unjustified expectations; comparisons need the ‘No aspect of this advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court of New Jersey’ disclaimer; quotes from judges need Guideline 3’s disclaimer.
Lead and case fee structures to put in front of New Jersey ethics counsel
These are the structures vendors sell. The right-hand column is what to ask, not a ruling: no rule we read approves or forbids a specific vendor contract.
| Structure | What the firm pays for | Question for ethics counsel |
|---|---|---|
| Advertising or flat program fee | Ad spend and campaign work, regardless of results | Is the fee a reasonable advertising cost under N.J. RPC 7.2(c), 7.3(d); CAA Op. 47/ACPE Op. 741 (June 21, 2021)? |
| Per-lead fee | Each inquiry delivered, owed whether or not the person hires the firm | Does the vendor recommend the firm or analyze the person’s case? Are its ads compliant if the firm made them? |
| Live transfer | Each connected call | Who speaks to the claimant first, and what do they say about the firm? |
| Fee per signed client | Each person who signs the firm’s retainer | Is the fee tied to the client hiring the firm, and does New Jersey treat that as paying for a recommendation or sharing a fee? |
| Firm-branded advertising run by a vendor | Ads in the firm’s name answered by the firm or its agent | Who is the firm’s agent in the solicitation, and do the runner statutes reach that contact? |
How CaseLead structures New Jersey engagements
CaseLead Agency runs paid acquisition on Meta and Google, qualifies callers by telephone and completes human intake. Outside Illinois and Arizona, it does not publish a per-signed-client price. In New Jersey it quotes per proposal and describes the arrangement in a structure the state allows, such as a flat program fee, a per-lead fee never tied to retention or firm-branded advertising. Have your ethics counsel read any vendor’s billable event and contact methods, including ours.
Questions law firms ask
Can a New Jersey lawyer pay a lead generation company?
RPC 7.2(c) bars giving anything of value for recommending the lawyer, except the reasonable cost of permitted advertising, RPC 1.17 sale costs, and usual charges of a not-for-profit lawyer referral service or legal service organization. RPC 7.3(d) separately bars paying anyone to recommend or secure employment.
Does New Jersey have a waiting period before contacting accident victims?
30-day bar on unsolicited direct contact with a prospective client after a specific mass-disaster event, when the contact concerns compensation from that event. Applies to any form of contact or written/electronic communication by a lawyer.
Is it a crime to act as a runner or capper in New Jersey?
Knowingly acting as a runner, or using, soliciting, directing, hiring or employing a runner, is a crime. A runner is a person who for pecuniary benefit procures or attempts to procure a client in cooperation with a provider (defined to include an attorney) seeking insurance benefits or asserting a claim against an insured or insurer.
Do New Jersey lawyers have to file their ads with the bar?
No rule read requires filing ads or solicitation letters. Any New Jersey lawyer may ask the Committee on Attorney Advertising for an advisory opinion on an ad; an approving opinion bars ethics charges except for a charge that the ad is false or misleading under RPC 7.1(a)(1), and using a disapproved ad is per se unethical.
Can a lead vendor charge a New Jersey firm per signed client?
New Jersey ACPE Opinion 741 (2021) separates a per-lead fee, which a firm may pay as an advertising cost, from a fee per client retained, which it treats as an improper referral fee. Several states’ bar opinions treat a fee owed only when a client signs as a referral fee, so have ethics counsel review it before you buy.
Sources and further reading
- RPC 7.3(b)(4): 30-day bar on unsolicited direct contact after a specific mass-disaster event (checked November 13, 2026)
- RPC 7.2(c): no value for recommending, exceptions (checked November 13, 2026)
- CAA Op. 47/ACPE Op. 741 (2021): per lead OK, per client retained not (checked November 13, 2026)
- R. 1:19A-3: voluntary advisory opinions from the Committee on Attorney Advertising (checked November 13, 2026)
- RPC 7.1(a)(2) (checked November 13, 2026)
Tell us which cases your firm wants.
Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.
Discuss your case criteria