Can a Pennsylvania law firm pay for leads?
Rule 7.2(b) bars paying for recommendations except reasonable ad costs, usual charges of a lawyer referral service or legal service plan, and Rule 1.17 practice purchases. Comment (4) allows paying lead generators that do not recommend the lawyer, with payment consistent with Rules 1.5(e) and 5.4. Pennsylvania adds 7.2(i) (paying for another lawyer’s or a for-profit entity’s ad requires disclosing all payers and how referrals are made) and 7.2(j) (no advertising as a pretext to refer cases). Paying a nonlawyer to recommend is also a crime under 18 Pa.C.S. 4117(b)(1).
In short: ABA Comment [5]-style lead-generator language adopted (as Comment (4)); plus PA-specific 7.2(i)-(j).
What decides most questions is the billable event. A fee for advertising, or a fee per lead that is owed whether or not the person hires the firm, is treated as an advertising cost in most states. A fee owed only when a client signs looks like payment for the referral. Bar opinions in other states treat a fee owed only when a client signs as a referral fee rather than an advertising cost: Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 18-1 (2018), New Jersey ACPE Opinion 741 (2021) and New York State Bar Opinions 1279 (2025) and 1294 (2026). Illinois has allowed a reasonable per-hire connecting fee under conditions since July 1, 2025, and Arizona allows referral fees.
The Pennsylvania rule text on paying for recommendations
Verbatim extracts from Pennsylvania Rules of Professional Conduct (204 Pa. Code ch. 81), read November 13, 2026. Pa. Code site reflects changes through 56 Pa.B. 6006 (Sept. 5, 2026). Rules 7.1, 7.2, 7.3 amended Oct. 15, 2024, effective in 30 days (54 Pa.B. 6696).
- “A lawyer shall not compensate, give or promise anything of value to a person for recommending the lawyer’s services except that a lawyer may: (1) pay the reasonable costs of advertisements or communications permitted by this Rule; (2) pay the usual charges of a lawyer referral service or legal service plan” (Rule 7.2(b))
- “A lawyer may pay others for generating client leads, such as Internet-based client leads, as long as the lead generator does not recommend the lawyer, any payment to the lead generator is consistent with Rules 1.5(e) (division of fees) and 5.4 (professional independence of the lawyer)” (Cmt (4): ABA-style lead-generator language)
- “A lawyer shall not, directly or indirectly (whether through an advertising cooperative or otherwise), pay all or any part of the costs of an advertisement by a lawyer not in the same firm or by any for-profit entity other than the lawyer’s firm, unless the advertisement discloses” (Rule 7.2(i): paying for ads by other lawyers / for-profit entities requires disclosure)
- “A lawyer or law firm shall not advertise as a pretext to refer cases obtained from advertising to other lawyers.” (Rule 7.2(j): no advertising as pretext to refer)
Pennsylvania runner, capper and solicitation statutes
The insurance fraud statute makes it a crime to solicit, for pecuniary gain, anyone to hire a person to prosecute a negligence claim, or to solicit others to bring personal injury or death claims (unless permitted by law or Supreme Court rule) - 4117(a)(8); for a lawyer to pay a nonlawyer to recommend or secure employment except reasonable advertising costs and not-for-profit referral service charges - 4117(b)(1); and for a lawyer or health care provider to pay for names/contact information of people receiving medical care for accident, sickness or disease - 4117(b)(3). Convicted lawyers are certified to the Disciplinary Board.
Penalties: (a)(8): felony of the third degree (max 7 years, 18 Pa.C.S. 1103(3); fine up to $15,000, 1101(3)). (b) offenses: misdemeanor of the first degree (max 5 years, 1104(1); fine up to $10,000, 1101(4)). Plus civil penalties up to $5,000 / $10,000 / $15,000 per violation (4117(j)).
For a firm buying leads or signed cases, the practical question is how the vendor reaches people: public advertising that the person answers is treated differently from an agent who approaches accident victims for the firm.
Contacting accident victims in Pennsylvania: waiting periods
Rule 7.3 has no post-accident waiting period. It bars live person-to-person solicitation for pecuniary gain (comment says this includes text messages), expressly permits targeted direct mail, and bars solicitation of people who cannot exercise reasonable judgment, who asked not to be contacted, or involving coercion. 18 Pa.C.S. 4117 (read) has no waiting period either.
Citation: Pa.R.P.C. 7.3(b)-(d) and cmt. (2).
Pennsylvania advertising filing and records
Rules 7.1-7.3 as amended Oct. 15, 2024 contain no requirement to file advertisements or solicitation letters with the Disciplinary Board or any other body. No voluntary review program was found in the rules read.
Current Rule 7.2 (amended Oct. 15, 2024) contains no ad-retention provision; a search of the rule text for ‘kept’ and ‘retain’ found only unrelated uses.
| Item | Pennsylvania |
|---|---|
| Filing or review required | no |
| Who reviews | None |
| Timing | None |
| Fee | not applicable |
| Record retention | no requirement in current rule |
| Citation | Pa.R.P.C. 7.1-7.3 (read in full) |
Testimonials and past results in ads
Paid endorsements must disclose that the endorser is paid; celebrity or public-figure endorsements are banned outright. A non-client may not portray a client, and re-enactments or non-authentic pictures/persons require a dramatization disclosure; non-lawyers may not portray lawyers. Comment (3) to Rule 7.1 says truthful past results can mislead if they create unjustified expectations; disclaimers may help. ‘No fee unless recovery’ ads must disclose client liability for expenses.
Lead and case fee structures to put in front of Pennsylvania ethics counsel
These are the structures vendors sell. The right-hand column is what to ask, not a ruling: no rule we read approves or forbids a specific vendor contract.
| Structure | What the firm pays for | Question for ethics counsel |
|---|---|---|
| Advertising or flat program fee | Ad spend and campaign work, regardless of results | Is the fee a reasonable advertising cost under Pa.R.P.C. 7.2(b), (i), (j) and cmt. (4); 18 Pa.C.S. 4117(b)(1)? |
| Per-lead fee | Each inquiry delivered, owed whether or not the person hires the firm | Does the vendor recommend the firm or analyze the person’s case? Are its ads compliant if the firm made them? |
| Live transfer | Each connected call | Who speaks to the claimant first, and what do they say about the firm? |
| Fee per signed client | Each person who signs the firm’s retainer | Is the fee tied to the client hiring the firm, and does Pennsylvania treat that as paying for a recommendation or sharing a fee? |
| Firm-branded advertising run by a vendor | Ads in the firm’s name answered by the firm or its agent | Who is the firm’s agent in the solicitation, and do the runner statutes reach that contact? |
How CaseLead structures Pennsylvania engagements
CaseLead Agency runs paid acquisition on Meta and Google, qualifies callers by telephone and completes human intake. Outside Illinois and Arizona, it does not publish a per-signed-client price. In Pennsylvania it quotes per proposal and describes the arrangement in a structure the state allows, such as a flat program fee, a per-lead fee never tied to retention or firm-branded advertising. Have your ethics counsel read any vendor’s billable event and contact methods, including ours.
Questions law firms ask
Can a Pennsylvania lawyer pay a lead generation company?
Rule 7.2(b) bars paying for recommendations except reasonable ad costs, usual charges of a lawyer referral service or legal service plan, and Rule 1.17 practice purchases. Comment (4) allows paying lead generators that do not recommend the lawyer, with payment consistent with Rules 1.5(e) and 5.4.
Does Pennsylvania have a waiting period before contacting accident victims?
Rule 7.3 has no post-accident waiting period. It bars live person-to-person solicitation for pecuniary gain (comment says this includes text messages), expressly permits targeted direct mail, and bars solicitation of people who cannot exercise reasonable judgment, who asked not to be contacted, or involving coercion. 18 Pa.C.S. 4117 (read) has no waiting period either.
Is it a crime to act as a runner or capper in Pennsylvania?
The insurance fraud statute makes it a crime to solicit, for pecuniary gain, anyone to hire a person to prosecute a negligence claim, or to solicit others to bring personal injury or death claims (unless permitted by law or Supreme Court rule) - 4117(a)(8); for a lawyer to pay a nonlawyer to recommend or secure employment except reasonable advertising costs and not-for-profit referral service charges - 4117(b)(1); and for a lawyer or health care provider to pay for names/contact information of people receiving medical care for accident, sickness or disease - 4117(b)(3). Convicted lawyers are certified to the Disciplinary Board.
Do Pennsylvania lawyers have to file their ads with the bar?
Rules 7.1-7.3 as amended Oct. 15, 2024 contain no requirement to file advertisements or solicitation letters with the Disciplinary Board or any other body. No voluntary review program was found in the rules read.
Can a lead vendor charge a Pennsylvania firm per signed client?
We found no Pennsylvania rule text that addresses that billable event directly. Several states’ bar opinions treat a fee owed only when a client signs as a referral fee, so have ethics counsel review it before you buy.
Sources and further reading
- Rule 7.3(c): targeted direct mail permitted (no waiting period in text) (checked November 13, 2026)
- 18 Pa.C.S. 4117(a)(8): soliciting negligence/PI claims for pecuniary gain (checked November 13, 2026)
- 18 Pa.C.S. 1103(3): F3 max (checked November 13, 2026)
- 18 Pa.C.S. 1104(1): M1 max (checked November 13, 2026)
- 18 Pa.C.S. 1101: max fines F3 / M1 (checked November 13, 2026)
- Pennsylvania Rules of Professional Conduct (204 Pa. Code ch. 81) (checked November 13, 2026)
- Rule 7.1 cmt (3): past results may mislead (checked November 13, 2026)
Tell us which cases your firm wants.
Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.
Discuss your case criteria