Utah ethics rules

Utah lawyer lead generation rules: can a firm pay for leads?

Utah lawyers may pay reasonable advertising costs, but the rules we read bar paying anyone to recommend the lawyer or refer a matter. Effective Nov. 1, 2026, Utah Rule 5.4(c) states ‘Referral fees are prohibited,’ and Rule 1.0 defines a referral fee as compensation ‘for the sole purpose of referring a legal matter’ paid to anyone outside the firm. Rule 1.0 comment [9] says fees for generating consumer interest, ‘including lead generation service providers, online banner advertising, pay-per-click marketing’, are not referral fees. (Utah R. Prof. Conduct 1.0(q) & cmt [9], 5.4(c), 5.8 (eff. Nov. 1, 2026); Utah Code 78B-3-111; 76-17-202; 13-68-101, -201; Utah Ethics Op. 25-02.) Utah also has runner, capper or solicitation statutes (Utah Code 76-17-201, 76-17-202; Utah Code 13-68-201, 13-68-401, 13-68-402), so a vendor’s contact methods matter as much as its fee. Rules and statutes checked on official sites through November 13, 2026. CaseLead Agency, which publishes this page, quotes Utah engagements per proposal.

Can a Utah law firm pay for leads?

Effective Nov. 1, 2026, Utah Rule 5.4(c) states ‘Referral fees are prohibited,’ and Rule 1.0 defines a referral fee as compensation ‘for the sole purpose of referring a legal matter’ paid to anyone outside the firm. Rule 1.0 comment [9] says fees for generating consumer interest, ‘including lead generation service providers, online banner advertising, pay-per-click marketing’, are not referral fees. This supersedes Ethics Op. 25-02 (Aug. 2025), which had found no per se ban after the 2020 repeal of Rule 7.2. Statutory overlays: Utah Code 78B-3-111 lets a client recover an undisclosed client referral fee paid to a non-attorney, excepting marketing/PPC payments ‘not contingent on whether the attorney or the law firm retains a client’; 76-17-202 criminalizes kickbacks for referrals relating to damages claims; ch. 13-68 regulates lawyer referral consultants (digital marketing services that do not contact prospects individually are excluded).

In short: No Rule 7.2 (reserved since 2020); new Rule 5.4(c) eff. Nov. 1, 2026 prohibits referral fees, but Rule 1.0 cmt [9] says lead-generation, banner and pay-per-click fees are not referral fees.

What decides most questions is the billable event. A fee for advertising, or a fee per lead that is owed whether or not the person hires the firm, is treated as an advertising cost in most states. A fee owed only when a client signs looks like payment for the referral. Bar opinions in other states treat a fee owed only when a client signs as a referral fee rather than an advertising cost: Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 18-1 (2018), New Jersey ACPE Opinion 741 (2021) and New York State Bar Opinions 1279 (2025) and 1294 (2026). Illinois has allowed a reasonable per-hire connecting fee under conditions since July 1, 2025, and Arizona allows referral fees.

The Utah rule text on paying for recommendations

Verbatim extracts from Utah Rules of Professional Conduct (now Supreme Court Rules of Professional Practice ch. 3; formerly UCJA ch. 13), read November 13, 2026. Rule 3-7.1 effective 5/1/2024; Rules 1.0, 5.4 and new 5.8 effective 11/1/2026 (pages printed Nov. 13, 2026). Rules 7.2-7.5 are reserved (eliminated 2020).

  • “(c) Referral fees are prohibited.” (Rule 5.4(c) effective 11/1/2026: referral fees prohibited)
  • “Effective: 11/1/2026 (a) A lawyer may provide legal services pursuant to this Rule only if” (Rule 5.4 effective date)
  • ““Referral fee” denotes compensation for the sole purpose of referring a legal matter paid to any person who is not in the same firm.” (Rule 1.0 definition of referral fee)

Utah runner, capper and solicitation statutes

Utah Code 76-17-202 makes it a crime to solicit/receive, or offer/pay, a kickback or bribe for referring a person to another person for a good or service relating to an insurance claim or a claim for damages (fees shared between licensed lawyers excluded; unpaid lawyer/medical referrals and certain lien payments and marketing to providers excepted). Utah Code ch. 13-68 (Lawyer Referral Consultants Registration Act) requires paid lawyer referral consultants to register with the Division of Consumer Protection and bars them or ‘another person’ from 30-day post-disaster/PI contact. No statute using ‘runner/capper’ terms was located.

Penalties: 76-17-202(3): ‘third degree felony’ (76-3-203(3): term ‘not to exceed five years’; 76-3-301: fine up to ‘$5,000 for a felony conviction of the third degree’). 13-68-402: administrative fine up to $2,500 per violation; court fine up to $2,500 per violation; intentional violation ‘is guilty of a class A misdemeanor; and (ii) may be fined up to $10,000’ (76-3-204: class A misdemeanor ‘not exceeding 364 days’).

For a firm buying leads or signed cases, the practical question is how the vendor reaches people: public advertising that the person answers is treated differently from an agent who approaches accident victims for the firm.

Contacting accident victims in Utah: waiting periods

Rule 7.1(c) (eff. May 1, 2024) bars a lawyer from directly communicating with a prospective client to obtain employment about a disaster or a personal injury/wrongful death action unless the event occurred more than 30 days before, the person has a familial, close personal or prior professional relationship with the lawyer or firm, or the contact is initiated by the prospective client or requested by a close family member/friend. The rule text is not limited to in-person contact. Separately, Utah Code 13-68-401(1)(d) makes the same 30-day contact unlawful for ‘a lawyer referral consultant or another person’ (communications to obtain or refer business).

Citation: Utah R. Prof. Conduct 7.1(c) (Sup. Ct. R. Prof. Practice 3-7.1(c)); Utah Code 13-68-401(1)(d).

Utah advertising filing and records

Utah’s only advertising rule is Rule 7.1 (Rules 7.2-7.5 are reserved); it contains no filing, pre-approval or advisory review requirement for ads or solicitations. Lawyer referral consultants (non-attorneys) must register with the Division of Consumer Protection under Utah Code 13-68-201, which is a registration of the consultant, not of ads.

Rule 7.1 has no record-retention requirement and Rule 7.2 (where the ABA-style retention provision historically sat) is ‘reserved’.

ItemUtah
Filing or review requiredno
Who reviewsnone
Timingn/a
Feen/a
Record retentionno requirement in current rules
CitationUtah R. Prof. Conduct 7.1; Rule 7.2 reserved

Testimonials and past results in ads

Rule 7.1(a) treats as false or misleading a communication likely to create an unjustified or unreasonable expectation about results the lawyer ‘can achieve or has achieved’, or one containing a testimonial or endorsement that violates the rule. Comment [3] permits ‘the use of actors or dramatizations to portray the lawyer, law firm, client, or events’ if not false or misleading; comment [4] says truthful reports of past results may mislead and an appropriate disclaimer may preclude that finding. No mandatory disclaimer text.

Lead and case fee structures to put in front of Utah ethics counsel

These are the structures vendors sell. The right-hand column is what to ask, not a ruling: no rule we read approves or forbids a specific vendor contract.

StructureWhat the firm pays forQuestion for ethics counsel
Advertising or flat program feeAd spend and campaign work, regardless of resultsIs the fee a reasonable advertising cost under Utah R. Prof. Conduct 1.0(q) & cmt [9], 5.4(c), 5.8 (eff. Nov. 1, 2026); Utah Code 78B-3-111; 76-17-202; 13-68-101, -201; Utah Ethics Op. 25-02?
Per-lead feeEach inquiry delivered, owed whether or not the person hires the firmDoes the vendor recommend the firm or analyze the person’s case? Are its ads compliant if the firm made them?
Live transferEach connected callWho speaks to the claimant first, and what do they say about the firm?
Fee per signed clientEach person who signs the firm’s retainerIs the fee tied to the client hiring the firm, and does Utah treat that as paying for a recommendation or sharing a fee?
Firm-branded advertising run by a vendorAds in the firm’s name answered by the firm or its agentWho is the firm’s agent in the solicitation, and do the runner statutes reach that contact?

How CaseLead structures Utah engagements

CaseLead Agency runs paid acquisition on Meta and Google, qualifies callers by telephone and completes human intake. Outside Illinois and Arizona, it does not publish a per-signed-client price. In Utah it quotes per proposal and describes the arrangement in a structure the state allows, such as a flat program fee, a per-lead fee never tied to retention or firm-branded advertising. Have your ethics counsel read any vendor’s billable event and contact methods, including ours.

Questions law firms ask

Can a Utah lawyer pay a lead generation company?

Effective Nov. 1, 2026, Utah Rule 5.4(c) states ‘Referral fees are prohibited,’ and Rule 1.0 defines a referral fee as compensation ‘for the sole purpose of referring a legal matter’ paid to anyone outside the firm. Rule 1.0 comment [9] says fees for generating consumer interest, ‘including lead generation service providers, online banner advertising, pay-per-click marketing’, are not referral fees.

Does Utah have a waiting period before contacting accident victims?

Rule 7.1(c) (eff. May 1, 2024) bars a lawyer from directly communicating with a prospective client to obtain employment about a disaster or a personal injury/wrongful death action unless the event occurred more than 30 days before, the person has a familial, close personal or prior professional relationship with the lawyer or firm, or the contact is initiated by the prospective client or requested by a close family member/friend.

Is it a crime to act as a runner or capper in Utah?

Utah Code 76-17-202 makes it a crime to solicit/receive, or offer/pay, a kickback or bribe for referring a person to another person for a good or service relating to an insurance claim or a claim for damages (fees shared between licensed lawyers excluded; unpaid lawyer/medical referrals and certain lien payments and marketing to providers excepted). Utah Code ch. 13-68 (Lawyer Referral Consultants Registration Act) requires paid lawyer referral consultants to register with the Division of Consumer Protection and bars them or ‘another person’ from 30-day post-disaster/PI contact.

Do Utah lawyers have to file their ads with the bar?

Utah’s only advertising rule is Rule 7.1 (Rules 7.2-7.5 are reserved); it contains no filing, pre-approval or advisory review requirement for ads or solicitations. Lawyer referral consultants (non-attorneys) must register with the Division of Consumer Protection under Utah Code 13-68-201, which is a registration of the consultant, not of ads.

Can a lead vendor charge a Utah firm per signed client?

We found no Utah rule text that addresses that billable event directly. Several states’ bar opinions treat a fee owed only when a client signs as a referral fee, so have ethics counsel review it before you buy.

Sources and further reading

Your firm's acquisition brief

Tell us which cases your firm wants.

Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.

Discuss your case criteria