Signed cases vs Google Ads

Should a personal injury firm buy signed cases or run its own Google Ads for car accident clients?

Buy signed cases if you need clients now, lack always-on intake or are entering a new market. Run Google Ads if you have strong intake and want a channel you control over time. Clicks are expensive: published estimates put terms such as “personal injury lawyer” at about $110 and “auto accident injury attorney” at about $155. Pareto Legal, an agency, reports about $4,046 per signed case for MVA paid media, above published signed retainer prices of about $1,775–$3,800. CaseLead Agency, which publishes this guide, charges $2,800–$3,800. Many firms do both.

How do signed cases and Google Ads compare?

The cost can land in a similar place. The difference is who carries the risk and what you own afterward.

QuestionBuying signed casesRunning your own Google Ads
Cost per signed casePublished prices about $1,775–$3,800; CaseLead $2,800–$3,800Vendor claims: $4,046 for MVA paid media (Pareto Legal); $1,200–$6,000 (MVA Leads)
Who pays for clicks that never signThe provider, up to the signatureYour firm
Staff neededFile review and onboardingIntake for every call and form, at all hours, plus someone managing the account
Time to first caseSet by the provider’s pacing and your proposalCan start quickly, but needs time to tune
What you own afterwardYour client filesAccount data, landing pages and what you learned
Rules to checkState limits on fees tied to a signed clientLawyer advertising rules for your ads and pages

How expensive are personal injury Google Ads clicks?

Very, and the published figures vary by keyword and method. Fraud Blocker, using Ahrefs data, lists about $110 for “personal injury lawyer,” $145 for “car injury attorney” and $155 for “auto accident injury attorney.” Ahrefs lists “commercial vehicle accident lawyer” at $100 and shows 37 or more legal terms among its 100 most expensive keywords.

Broad legal averages look much lower: LocaliQ reports an average cost per click of $9.87 and an average cost per lead of $131.63 for attorneys and legal services across its data. That average includes cheaper practice areas, so do not budget personal injury from it.

What does a Google Ads lead cost a personal injury firm?

Published vendor figures differ widely, partly because of what they count as a lead. Pareto Legal reports $272 per lead and $4,046 per signed case for personal injury MVA paid media across six firms, and $192 and $3,812 for Google Ads across its 12-firm sample of all practice areas. Pioneerly claims $500–$1,200 or more per lead for personal injury Google Ads. MVA Leads, which sells leads, says a firm’s own paid search runs $15,000–$30,000 a month in a competitive metro. Rankings.io, which runs ads for firms, describes measurable return as taking shape at six to twelve months.

When should a firm buy signed cases?

Signed cases tend to fit these situations.

  • Your phones are not reliably answered after hours
  • You want cases in a state or metro where you have no marketing
  • You want a known price per retainer instead of a monthly variable result
  • You lack someone to manage ad accounts well
  • You have case capacity now and do not want to wait for a channel to mature

When should a firm run its own Google Ads?

Your own ads tend to fit these situations.

  • You already sign a high share of inquiries, quickly
  • You want brand presence and data that stay with the firm
  • You can fund months of learning before it pays back
  • Your state’s rules make per-case buying difficult
  • You can compare the result with other channels on cost per accepted case

How do you test the two against each other?

Run them in the same state over the same months, with the same intake team and written criteria. Count every dollar on the ads side, including agency fees and staff time. Then compare cost per case your firm accepts, because that is the only number both routes share.

Can a firm do both?

Yes, and many do. Use signed cases to hit a volume target while your own ads and search mature, and measure both on cost per accepted case over the same period. CaseLead Agency runs paid acquisition on Meta and Google, qualifies callers by telephone, completes human intake and coordinates your retainer, at $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer. Ask your ethics counsel about any per-case fee in your state.

Questions law firms ask

Is it cheaper to buy signed cases or run Google Ads?

It depends on your intake. Published figures overlap, at about $1,775–$3,800 for signed retainers and about $4,046 per signed case for MVA paid media in one agency’s study. Strong intake favors your own ads, and weak intake favors signed cases.

How much do car accident Google Ads cost per click?

Published estimates for injury terms run from about $100 to $210 per click, depending on the keyword and market.

Should a small firm run Google Ads for car accidents?

Only with budget for months of learning and reliable intake. At $100 or more a click, a small budget buys few leads.

Sources and further reading

Your firm's acquisition brief

Tell us which cases your firm wants.

Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.

Discuss your case criteria