Marketing agencies

Personal injury marketing agencies compared: fees, contracts and exclusivity

Five of the 13 law firm marketing agencies we checked publish real fees. Published SEO retainers start at $1,500–$5,000 a month and reach $25,000–$100,000+ for multi-office firms, and PPC management runs 20% of ad spend at Juris Digital and PaperStreet or a flat $1,150–$4,500 a month at Grow Law, with the ad budget on top. Contracts range from month to month to 12 months, and only a few promise one firm per market. An agency builds marketing your firm keeps and your team still signs every client; CaseLead Agency, which publishes this guide, instead charges $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer.

Personal injury marketing agencies compared

Fees, terms and exclusivity as each agency publishes them on its own site, checked November 12, 2026. Ad spend is paid on top of any management fee.

AgencyPublished feesContract termsMarket exclusivity
Juris DigitalSEO from $2,000–$3,500 a month for a solo firm to $25,000–$100,000+ for multi-office firms; PPC 20% of ad spend plus a setup feeIts homepage asks for a 12-month campaign agreement; its PPC page says no long-term contractNot guaranteed; it discloses whether it serves another PI firm in your market
PaperStreetGoogle Ads management 20% of ad spend for budgets of $4,500 a month or more; websites from about $3,000 in the first year to $40,000+; SEO from “several thousands of dollars” a monthPPC month to month; SEO term not publishedExclusive by practice and geographic area
Grow Law (formerly Grow Law Firm)SEO from $2,500, $3,500 or $5,000 a month; PPC flat $1,150–$4,500 a month by ad budget, no setup fee3-month minimum for PPC (6 with SEO), then month to month on 30 days’ noticeNot stated
On The Map MarketingPPC $1,000 or 10% of budget, whichever is greater; SEO $1,500–$15,000+ a month; websites $5,000–$15,000+Not publishedNot offered on the pages we read
WEBRISPersonal injury SEO typically from $5,000 a month; a $2,500–$3,000 monthly minimum ad budget for its Facebook car accident funnelNot publishedNot promised
Hennessey DigitalEstimates only: most firms invest $6,000–$60,000 a month in personal injury SEOMonth to month, no lock-insNot stated
Custom Legal MarketingNot publishedNot publishedOne law firm per practice area per city
PostaliNot publishedNot publishedSEO clients are the only firm in their practice area and geography
ConsultwebsNot publishedNot publishedMay agree exclusivity depending on the situation
Esquire DigitalNot publishedNo long-term SEO contracts; most PPC month to monthNot stated
Market My MarketNot publishedNot publishedNot stated
Nifty MarketingNot publishedNot publishedNot stated
BluShark DigitalNot publishedNot publishedNot stated

How much does a personal injury marketing agency cost?

Published SEO floors are $1,500 a month at On The Map Marketing, which works across industries, $2,000 at Juris Digital, $2,500 at Grow Law and $5,000 at WEBRIS for personal injury. Juris Digital’s top band is $25,000–$100,000+ a month for multi-office firms, and Hennessey Digital estimates that most firms invest $6,000–$60,000 a month.

Paid search is a management fee plus the ad budget. Grow Law says personal injury firms spending under about $7,000 a month on Google Ads are not a fit, and PaperStreet’s 20% fee applies to budgets of $4,500 a month or more. Ask for the fee, the ad budget and any setup or website cost as separate lines.

Contracts and minimums

Terms vary more than prices. Hennessey Digital and Esquire Digital publish month-to-month terms, and Rankings.io says the same. Grow Law sets a three-month minimum for PPC and six months with SEO. Juris Digital’s homepage asks for a 12-month campaign agreement while its PPC page says no long-term contract, and Scorpion typically uses 12-month contracts for SEO and its technology. Most of the agencies we checked publish no term at all, so get it in writing, with the notice period and what you keep if you leave.

Will the agency work for your competitor?

Only some agencies promise one firm per market. Custom Legal Marketing commits to one law firm per practice area per city, PaperStreet says its services are exclusive by practice and geographic area, and Postali says SEO clients are the only firm in their practice area and geography. Consultwebs may agree exclusivity depending on the situation, and Juris Digital discloses whether it serves another personal injury firm in your market. If exclusivity matters to you, write the territory and practice area into the contract.

Ask for cost per signed case

Several agencies now say they report signed cases, not clicks: Grow Law, Hennessey Digital and WEBRIS each say so on their own sites. Ask any agency how it will tie a signed case, and its fee, back to the ad or page that produced it, and whether that depends on your intake team logging the source.

Agency case studies are vendor claims. Consultwebs says its clients average a 300% increase in signed cases and WEBRIS cites a client with 200+ signed cases in eight months; we did not verify either.

Agency or signed cases?

An agency builds search rankings, ads and a website your firm keeps, and the work compounds over months or years. Your team still answers every inquiry and signs every client, and the cost per case depends on how well that goes. WEBRIS argues that relying on bought leads is “a subscription to someone else’s business.”

A signed-case provider delivers clients now, at a known price per case, and you keep nothing when you stop. Many firms run both: an agency for long-term growth, and signed cases to fill capacity while it builds. CaseLead runs paid acquisition, qualifies callers by telephone, completes human intake and coordinates the signature on your firm’s retainer, at $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer.

Questions law firms ask

What is the best marketing agency for personal injury lawyers?

It depends on your market and budget. Of the agencies we checked, Juris Digital, Grow Law, PaperStreet, On The Map Marketing and WEBRIS publish fees, and Custom Legal Marketing, PaperStreet and Postali promise one firm per market. Compare them on fees, contract term, exclusivity and whether they report signed cases.

How much does personal injury marketing cost per month?

Published agency SEO retainers start at $1,500–$5,000 a month, and PPC management runs 20% of ad spend or a flat $1,150–$4,500 a month, plus the ad budget. Grow Law says personal injury firms spending under about $7,000 a month on Google Ads are not a fit.

Do legal marketing agencies require long-term contracts?

Some do. Grow Law sets a three-month PPC minimum, six with SEO; Juris Digital’s homepage asks for a 12-month campaign; Hennessey Digital and Esquire Digital publish month-to-month terms. Most agencies publish no term.

Will a marketing agency work with competing firms in my city?

Ask. Custom Legal Marketing, PaperStreet and Postali state one firm per market; most others publish nothing, so put the territory in the contract.

Is it better to hire an agency or buy signed cases?

They do different jobs. An agency builds marketing you keep, over months, while your team does the intake. Signed cases arrive now at a fixed price per case. Many firms use both.

Sources and further reading

Your firm's acquisition brief

Tell us which cases your firm wants.

Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.

Discuss your case criteria