Cost per signed case

What is a typical cost per signed personal injury case when buying from a lead vendor?

Most published 2026 figures for an average personal injury signed case fall between about $2,000 and $4,000, but nearly all of them are vendor claims with different definitions. Pioneerly claims an average of $2,956, Pareto Legal reports $4,046 for MVA paid media across six firms, and signed retainers are published at about $1,775–$3,800. CaseLead Agency, which publishes this guide, charges $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer. Test any figure yourself by dividing total cost by the cases your firm accepted.

What do published sources say a signed personal injury case costs?

Every figure below is what the named source claims, and most sell something related. No neutral national benchmark exists that we could find.

SourceChannel or groupClaimed cost per signed case
Pioneerly (vendor claim)Average personal injury firm; top 25% in the second figure$2,956; $1,631
Pareto Legal (vendor claim)MVA paid media across six firms$4,046
Pareto Legal (vendor claim)Google Ads; Local Services Ads, across 12 firms in all practice areas$3,812; $2,354
Pareto Legal (vendor claim)MVA Local Services Ads, in a separate page$3,207
MVA Leads (vendor claim)Exclusive leads; live transfers; shared leads$3,900–$11,050; $400–$1,600; $800–$3,900
MVA Leads (vendor claim)A firm’s own paid search$1,200–$6,000
Inovista (derived from others’ figures)Exclusive leads; shared leads$1,250–$3,000; $1,667–$5,000
Providers’ published signed pricesStandard signed MVA retainerAbout $1,775–$3,800

Why do these numbers disagree so much?

They measure different things. “Signed” may mean a signed agreement, or a case the firm actually kept. “Cost” may include only ad spend, or also agency fees and intake staff. Some samples are a handful of firms, and each source has something to sell.

Some figures do not survive simple arithmetic. Rankings.io’s lead-cost article gives $284 per lead and a 7% lead-to-case rate beside a $468 cost per signed case. But $284 divided by 7% is about $4,057. Do this check on any figure you are quoted.

How do you calculate your own cost per signed case?

Use one delivery group and one stated date, so the number can be reproduced.

StepWhat to doExample
1. Add the costsVendor charges, ad spend and agency fees for one group of leads$30,000
2. Subtract confirmed creditsOnly credits you have actually received$30,000 − $2,000 = $28,000
3. Add intake laborReport it separately if you are comparing with signed cases$3,000
4. Divide by signed casesClients who signed your retainer$31,000 ÷ 10 = $3,100
5. Repeat for accepted casesKeep pending reviews out of the count$31,000 ÷ 8 = $3,875

How should you compare a lead price with a signed case price?

Turn them into the same unit. A $400 lead at a 15% sign rate costs about $2,667 per signed case before your staff time. A signed retainer at $2,800–$3,800 already includes acquisition, screening and intake. If your sign rate is strong and your intake is staffed, leads can cost less. If your sign rate is low or unmeasured, the fixed price is easier to budget and easier to compare.

Which channel has the lowest cost per signed case?

The honest answer is that it depends on who is reporting. In Pareto Legal’s sample of all practice areas, Local Services Ads beat Google Ads at $2,354 against $3,812. MVA Leads, which sells live transfers, claims they cost $400–$1,600 per signed case, far below its own exclusive leads at $3,900–$11,050. Each source has a commercial reason to favor some channels, so use these figures to choose what to test, then decide on your own numbers.

What should you do with these numbers?

Treat published figures as a reason to ask questions, not as a target. Start with your own history if you have one, and run a small test if you do not.

  • Ask every vendor what “signed” means and what the figure includes
  • Ask how many firms and which dates are behind any benchmark
  • Track cost per signed and cost per accepted separately
  • Compare channels over the same period, with the same intake team

Questions law firms ask

What is a good cost per signed personal injury case?

There is no neutral benchmark, but many published vendor figures sit between about $2,000 and $4,000. A good number is one that leaves margin at your own average fee and acceptance rate.

Does cost per signed case include intake staff?

Often not, and that is one reason figures differ. Ask what is included, and report intake labor separately when comparing leads with signed cases.

How much does CaseLead charge per signed case?

$2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer, set by state, case criteria, exclusivity and monthly volume. Commercial-vehicle and catastrophic cases are quoted separately.

Why are published cost benchmarks unreliable?

They usually come from small samples of one vendor’s own clients, and a vendor that sells a channel has reason to show it well. Ask for the sample size, the dates and exactly what is counted.

Sources and further reading

Your firm's acquisition brief

Tell us which cases your firm wants.

Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.

Discuss your case criteria