MVA lead sign rates

What is a good sign rate for purchased motor vehicle accident leads?

Published claims put exclusive MVA form leads at roughly 10–20% signed, live transfers at roughly 15–35% and shared leads at 2–6%. All of these come from vendors and agencies with their own definitions, so treat them as a starting point. A good sign rate is one that gives you a cost per signed case you can live with: at $400 per lead, 15% means about $2,667 per signed case. CaseLead Agency, which publishes this guide, sells signed MVA retainers at $2,800–$3,800, which removes sign-rate risk.

What sign rates do vendors and agencies claim?

We could find no neutral study of purchased MVA leads. Every row below is a claim by the party named, as of November 3, 2026.

SourceProductClaimed sign rate
MVA LeadsExclusive leads, standard auto10–15%
MVA LeadsExclusive leads: motorcycle; pedestrian; commercial truck9–14%; 8–13%; 6–11%
MVA LeadsLive-transfer calls15–25%
MVA LeadsShared leads; aged leads3–6%; 1–3%
PinPoint Legal MarketingExclusive form leadsFirms with good intake 15–20%; its FAQ says most report 15–30%
RingOnDemandLive transfers25–35%
Rankings.ioShared leads2–5%
Inovista, crediting Rankings.ioExclusive live-transfer leads20%
Pareto LegalMVA paid media; MVA Local Services Ads6.7%; 10%
PioneerlyAll inquiries at an average PI firm; top 25%10.6%; 21.7%

Why do sign rates vary so much?

The bottom of the fraction changes. A vendor may count every lead delivered, or only leads your team reached, or only callers who passed screening. The top changes too: “signed” may mean a signed retainer or a case your firm kept. So compare rates only when the definitions match.

  • Exclusivity: on shared leads, you are racing other firms
  • Case type: vendors claim lower rates for commercial truck and wrongful death leads
  • Speed: how quickly your team first reaches the lead
  • Coverage: whether anyone answers at night and on weekends
  • Screening: a form check passes more people than a phone conversation

How does sign rate change your cost per signed case?

Divide the price per lead by your sign rate. These are illustrations, before your staff time.

Price per lead10% signed15% signed20% signed30% signed
$350$3,500$2,333$1,750$1,167
$500$5,000$3,333$2,500$1,667
$800$8,000$5,333$4,000$2,667

How should a contract define a signed lead?

If a vendor quotes you a sign rate or ties anything to one, get the definitions in writing, because the same file can count as signed under one definition and not another.

  • What counts in the denominator: every lead delivered, or only leads reached?
  • What counts as signed: a signature on your retainer, or your firm’s acceptance?
  • How long after delivery a signature still counts
  • Whether replaced or credited leads are removed from the count
  • Whose data settles a disagreement: yours or the vendor’s

How should you measure your own sign rate?

Measure one vendor at a time, over one delivery group, on a stated date. Count every lead delivered as the bottom number, then report contact rate and sign rate separately so you can see which step is losing people. Allow enough time for slow signers before you call the number final, and keep pending files out of the result.

What improves a sign rate?

Speed is the lever most firms can pull. In a 2025 test of 1,333 law firms, Hennessey Digital reports a median of 13 minutes to first personal outreach, with 25% responding in under five minutes and 26% not responding within seven days. An often-quoted 2007 study by InsideSales.com and James Oldroyd reports the odds of contacting a web lead fall 100 times at 30 minutes rather than 5. It is old, it was not about law firms, and it says it did not address close rates, so treat it as directional.

If your team cannot call fast at all hours, more leads will not fix that. That is when a product with intake already done, such as CaseLead’s signed MVA retainers at $2,800–$3,800, can cost less than it first appears.

Questions law firms ask

What is a good sign rate for MVA leads?

Published vendor claims for exclusive form leads run roughly 10–20%. Whether that is good for you depends on your price per lead: work out the cost per signed case and compare it with what you can afford.

What sign rate should I expect from live transfers?

Vendors claim roughly 15–35%. Your result depends on whether your staff always answer, and on whether they can sign the client on that call.

Do commercial truck leads sign at a lower rate?

MVA Leads claims 6–11% for commercial truck leads against 10–15% for standard auto. Fewer callers qualify, though each case that does may be worth more.

Why is my sign rate lower than the vendor says?

Definitions may differ, and vendors’ figures often reflect their best clients. Check your first-call time, your after-hours coverage and how many leads you actually reached.

Sources and further reading

Your firm's acquisition brief

Tell us which cases your firm wants.

Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.

Discuss your case criteria