How quickly do law firms actually respond?
These are tests of real firms by companies that sell to law firms. Their methods differ, so compare them with care.
| Test | Finding |
|---|---|
| Clio 2024, 500 US firms, phone | 40% answered, down from 56% in 2019; counting firms that missed the call and did not phone back, 48% were effectively unreachable |
| Clio 2024, email | 33% responded, down from 40% in 2019; 84% of those who replied did so within eight hours |
| Clio 2024, what callers got | Among firms answering, 41% gave rate information, 12% a cost estimate and 36% next steps |
| Hennessey Digital 2025, 1,333 firms, web form | Median 13 minutes to first personal outreach; 25% under five minutes; 56% within the hour; 26% no reply in seven days |
| Pioneerly (vendor claim) | Average PI firm’s first response in office hours is 15.7 minutes; under 2 minutes for the top 25% |
What does speed-to-lead research actually show?
The figure everyone quotes comes from a 2007 study by InsideSales.com and James Oldroyd. It reports that the odds of contacting a web lead fall 100 times, and of qualifying it 21 times, if the call comes at 30 minutes rather than 5. It covered web leads across industries, and it says it did not address close rates. A 2011 Harvard Business Review article by Oldroyd and others drew a similar conclusion, reportedly from an audit of 2,241 US companies.
So treat the exact multiples with care, because they are old, come from a company selling sales software and are not about legal clients. The direction is plausible for injury claimants, who may be calling several firms, and a consumer study relayed by Pareto Legal says 80% contact another attorney after 48 hours without a reply.
What happens when a firm does answer?
Answering is only the start. Among firms that answered Clio’s 2024 phone test, ABA Journal reports that 41% gave rate information, 12% offered a cost estimate and 36% walked the caller through next steps. Only 12% of Clio’s secret shoppers said they were likely to recommend the firm they contacted. For an injury claimant, a clear next step can matter as much as a fast answer, so write down what the first call must cover.
What should your target be?
Set a target you can actually hold at all hours, then measure it weekly.
- Live calls: answered by a person, every time, during every hour you advertise
- Web forms and purchased leads: first call within five minutes during coverage hours
- After hours: a named person or service, not voicemail
- Follow-up: a written schedule of attempts, within your consent and state rules
- Every lead: a recorded first-contact time, so you can see the real number
How do you measure first-call time?
Use delivery time from the vendor and the first dial from your phone or CRM. Report the median and the slowest quarter, and split by hour of day, because the average hides your nights and weekends. Test your own firm too: have someone submit a form at 9 p.m. on a Sunday, and see what happens.
What if you cannot respond that fast?
Then be careful about buying form leads, because you will pay for people who have moved on. You can add after-hours intake, buy live transfers only for staffed hours, or buy a product where intake is finished before it reaches you. CaseLead’s team qualifies callers by telephone, completes human intake and coordinates your retainer, at $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer.
Questions law firms ask
How quickly should a law firm call back a lead?
Within minutes if you can. The research behind that is older and not specific to law firms, but injury claimants often contact several firms, and the firms that respond first have the chance to help.
Should we use an answering service for leads?
It can cover nights and weekends. Check that its staff can screen against your criteria, and that a person on your team follows up quickly. Test it the way you would test your own line.
Do law firms answer their phones?
Often not. In Clio’s 2024 test of 500 US firms, 40% answered the phone, down from 56% in 2019.
What is a good speed-to-lead benchmark for law firms?
In Hennessey Digital’s 2025 test, the median was 13 minutes and the fastest quarter of firms responded in under five. Aim for under five minutes during coverage hours.
Sources and further reading
- Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism, on the 2024 Clio test
- ABA Journal, on the 2024 Clio test
- Hennessey Digital, 2025 lead-form response study (vendor research)
- InsideSales.com and James Oldroyd, lead response study (2007)
- Harvard Business Review, The Short Life of Online Sales Leads (2011)
- Pioneerly, personal injury intake and cost figures (vendor claims)
- CaseLead Agency, signed MVA cases (publisher)
Tell us which cases your firm wants.
Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.
Discuss your case criteria