Intake metrics

Personal injury intake KPIs: what to track, how to define each, and a weekly scorecard

A personal injury intake team should track six numbers each week: speed to first call, contact rate, qualification rate, sign rate, cost per signed case and unsigned follow-up. Each needs a fixed numerator, denominator and cutoff, or the figures cannot be compared week to week. Published benchmarks with a named source are thin and none is specific to personal injury sign rates. In Clio’s 2024 secret-shopper test of 500 U.S. firms, 40% answered the phone and 33% answered an email. Hennessey Digital, a law-firm marketing agency, reports a median of 13 minutes to first personal outreach across 1,333 firms in 2025, with 26% not responding within seven days. Both come from companies that sell to law firms, so treat them as context and set targets from your own history. CaseLead Agency publishes this guide.

The six intake KPIs and how to define each

Count one inquiry per person per accident, merge duplicates, and exclude spam, vendors and existing clients before you compute anything. Group inquiries by the week they arrived, and state the cutoff date at which you counted outcomes.

KPINumeratorDenominatorDefinition notes
Speed to first callMinutes from receipt to the first outbound attempt by a personEach form, chat or missed callReport the median and the share under 5 minutes. An auto-reply does not count. For answered inbound calls, report rings or seconds to answer
Contact rateInquiries with a two-way conversation by the cutoffAll unique eligible inquiriesA voicemail or unanswered text is an attempt, not a contact
Qualification rateContacted inquiries that meet the firm’s written criteriaContacted inquiriesUse the criteria version in force that week. Record the reason for each rejection
Sign rateSigned retainersQualified inquiries, and separately all inquiriesAlways say which denominator. “Signed” means the client’s signature is complete, not that the agreement was sent
Cost per signed caseMarketing or vendor spend plus intake labor for the cohortSigned cases from that cohortCount cases the firm later rejects separately, and show cost per retained case too
Unsigned follow-upRetainers sent but unsigned that got every scheduled touchRetainers sent but unsignedAlso report how many signed after day 1, and how many were closed as lost with a reason

Speed to first call: the published numbers

Hennessey Digital submitted web forms to 1,333 U.S. law firms in the first quarter of 2025 and timed the first personal outreach. It reports a median of 13 minutes, 25% of firms under five minutes, 33% at ten minutes or less and 56% within the hour. It counted a firm as non-responsive after seven days, and 26% were. The sample included personal injury firms but the page gives no personal injury breakout, and the firms came from marketing-industry lists, so they are not a random sample.

One limit matters for intake directors: every form was sent between 10 a.m. and 12 p.m. in the firm’s local time. The study says nothing about nights or weekends. Measure those hours yourself.

Contact rate: the published numbers

Clio’s 2024 test had a research company contact 500 U.S. law firms as prospective clients. As summarized by the Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism, 40% of firms answered the phone, down from 56% in 2019, and 33% responded to an email, down from 40%. Counting firms that neither answered nor called back, 48% were unreachable by phone.

That measures whether firms answer, which is the mirror image of your contact rate on forms: whether prospects answer you. No named neutral source publishes a contact-rate benchmark for personal injury web leads. Vendors quote figures; ask for the definition and the denominator before you compare.

Where no reliable benchmark exists

We found no primary or neutral source for qualification rate, sign rate, cost per signed case or follow-up conversion at personal injury firms. Figures in circulation come from agencies, lead vendors and software companies describing their own customers, usually without a stated denominator.

The practical answer is to benchmark against yourself. Hold the definitions fixed for eight weeks, split by source, and compare each source and each intake specialist with the firm’s own median. A change in criteria, hours or vendor mix will move every rate, so note those changes on the scorecard.

  • Vendor claim to test: “sign rate” quoted on qualified leads, not all leads
  • Vendor claim to test: “cost per case” that leaves out intake labor
  • Vendor claim to test: “contact rate” that counts a voicemail as a contact

A sample weekly scorecard

An invented week for a firm that received 100 unique inquiries, counted 14 days after the week closed. The numbers show the arithmetic only.

LineCount or valueRate and denominator
Unique eligible inquiries100 (108 received, 8 duplicates merged)Base for cohort rates
Median minutes to first attempt, forms6 minutes; 46% under 5 minutesOf 50 form inquiries
Contacted70Contact rate 70% of 100
Qualified28Qualification rate 40% of 70 contacted
Retainers sent2693% of 28 qualified
Signed20Sign rate 71% of 28 qualified; 20% of 100 inquiries
Unsigned after sending6; 5 received every scheduled touchFollow-up completion 83% of 6
Spend plus intake labor$30,000 media and vendors + $4,000 laborCost per signed case $1,700 ($34,000 ÷ 20)
Rejected after lawyer review2Cost per retained case $1,889 ($34,000 ÷ 18)

Cost per signed case: get the denominator right

Cost per signed case is the number partners care about and the easiest to flatter. Match spend to the cohort it produced, add the intake hours spent on that cohort, and divide by signatures from that cohort only. Then subtract the cases a lawyer rejects on review and divide again.

Compute it by source. A source with cheap leads and a low sign rate can cost more per signed case than an expensive one. The same test applies to buying signed cases: CaseLead Agency charges $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer where a per-case fee is allowed, and the fair comparison is your own fully loaded cost per retained case.

Unsigned follow-up: the metric most firms skip

Qualified callers who do not sign on the first call are the cheapest cases left to win, because the marketing and screening cost is already spent. Write a cadence, for example a call and text the same day, then days 1, 2, 4, 7 and 14, and measure whether every unsigned file got every touch.

Report three numbers: touches completed against touches scheduled, the share of signatures that came after the first day, and the closed-lost reasons. If “signed with another firm” leads the list, speed is the problem. If “could not reach” leads, look at hours and texting consent.

How to run the weekly review

Keep it to one page and one decision.

  • The intake director reconciles counts before the meeting: every inquiry has one current status
  • Compare this week with the trailing eight-week median, by source and by specialist
  • Listen to two recorded calls: one signed, one lost
  • Pick one correction, assign an owner and check it next week
  • Note any change to criteria, hours, staffing or vendors beside the numbers

Questions law firms ask

What KPIs should a personal injury intake team track?

Speed to first call, contact rate, qualification rate, sign rate, cost per signed case and unsigned follow-up. Define each with a fixed numerator, denominator and cutoff.

What is a good sign rate for personal injury intake?

No neutral source publishes one. Report sign rate on qualified inquiries and on all inquiries, by source, and compare against your own trailing median.

How fast do law firms respond to web leads?

Hennessey Digital’s 2025 test of 1,333 firms reports a median of 13 minutes to first personal outreach, with 25% under five minutes and 26% not responding within seven days. It is an agency’s own study.

How many law firms answer the phone?

In Clio’s 2024 test of 500 U.S. firms, 40% answered, down from 56% in 2019, as summarized by the Illinois Supreme Court Commission on Professionalism.

How do you calculate cost per signed case?

Add marketing or vendor spend and intake labor for a cohort of inquiries, then divide by the retainers signed from that cohort. Divide again by cases kept after lawyer review to get cost per retained case.

Does an auto-reply count as a response?

Not for speed to first call. Time the first attempt by a person, and track auto-replies separately.

Sources and further reading

Your firm's acquisition brief

Tell us which cases your firm wants.

Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.

Discuss your case criteria