How does $3,000 compare with the market?
It is near the middle of what vendors publish, checked November 3, 2026.
| Vendor | Published price for a standard signed case |
|---|---|
| Injury Case Claims | From $1,775 per standard case. State, accident date, criteria and volume affect the quote. Checked November 17, 2026. |
| RingOnDemand | $2,500 flat |
| CaseLead Agency (publisher of this page) | $2,800–$3,800 |
| getMVA | About $3,000 |
| Case Connect | Main programs require a state/program quote. Separate Feed offer: $3,000 per case plus $500/month. A separate promotion offers 15 completed intakes free and says most firms pay $2,000–$3,000 per completed intake. Request your written rate. |
| First Intent Leads | State and market rates are quoted by phone and confirmed in writing. Checked November 17, 2026; earlier dollar tiers are not verified current quotes. |
Does $3,000 make sense against an average fee?
Here is a rough check using public figures. Private passenger auto bodily injury claims averaged $28,278 per paid claim in 2024, according to the Insurance Information Institute, and the NAIC’s latest figure is $28,918.86 for 2022. Research on contingency fees finds most personal injury fees around one-third. A third of $28,278 is about $9,400, so $3,000 is about 32% of that fee.
Treat this as a sense check, not a forecast. These are averages across all paid bodily injury claims, not the cases your firm takes. The Insurance Research Council reports that attorney-represented claimants rose to nearly half of auto injury claimants by 2022, and your own results may be higher or lower. The calculation also leaves out your case costs, staff time and the cases that pay nothing.
What does your acceptance rate do to the price?
This table holds the price at $3,000 and assumes no replacements or credits. The fee is the $9,400 illustration above, so use your own number.
| Share of signed cases you accept | Cost per accepted case | Share of a $9,400 fee |
|---|---|---|
| 100% | $3,000 | 32% |
| 90% | $3,333 | 35% |
| 80% | $3,750 | 40% |
| 70% | $4,286 | 46% |
| 60% | $5,000 | 53% |
What makes $3,000 a good or bad price?
Two offers at $3,000 can be very different deals. Check these before you decide.
- Criteria: how recent is the accident, and is treatment already under way?
- State: some states have higher case values, and some bar fees tied to a signed client
- Replacements: can you return a file that fails your criteria, and for how long?
- Payment: half up front on 10 cases is about $15,000 before you see a file
- Advertising: is media included, or billed separately?
- Source: does the vendor generate claimants itself, or buy from others?
What would the same case cost another way?
Vendors’ figures for reaching a signed case by other routes give some context, though they carry the same limits as any vendor claim. Pioneerly claims an average of $2,956 across personal injury firms. Pareto Legal reports $4,046 for MVA paid media across six firms. MVA Leads claims $3,900–$11,050 buying its own exclusive leads at a 10–15% sign rate. So $3,000 for a claimant already signed is not obviously expensive, but none of these figures includes the same work, so compare your own costs where you can.
Is a per-signed-case price allowed in your state?
Not everywhere. Illinois allows a reasonable per-hire connecting fee under conditions and Arizona allows referral fees, while bar opinions, court decisions or statutes in several states treat a fee tied to a signed client as a prohibited referral payment. In those states, CaseLead uses a different structure and quotes per proposal. Ask your ethics counsel before you buy.
How should you decide?
Work out your own break-even: your average fee, less case costs, less the margin you need, is the most you can pay per accepted case. Then divide by your expected acceptance rate to get the most you can pay per signed case. CaseLead’s standard price of $2,800–$3,800 is set by state, case criteria and volume, and our calculator lets you run the same numbers on any proposal.
Questions law firms ask
Is $3,000 too much for a signed car accident case?
Not by published prices, which run from about $1,775 to $3,800. Whether it is too much for you depends on your average fee and how many of those cases you accept.
What is the average fee on an auto accident case?
We found no neutral national figure for fees on represented auto cases. As a rough check, a one-third fee on the $28,278 average bodily injury claim is about $9,400, but your cases may differ.
What is the most a firm should pay per signed case?
Take your average fee, subtract case costs and the margin you need, and multiply by your acceptance rate. That is your ceiling.
Sources and further reading
- CaseLead Agency, signed MVA cases (publisher)
- Insurance Information Institute, auto insurance facts
- NAIC, Auto Insurance Database Report
- Insurance Research Council, auto injury study release (2026)
- Engstrom, New York University Law Review (2011)
- First Intent program and quote details — selected offer checked 2026-11-17
- Injury Case Claims advertised starting price — selected offer checked 2026-11-17
- RingOnDemand, MVA prices
- Standard retainer pricing and minimum — selected offer checked 2026-11-17
- Case Connect: programs and completed-intake process — checked November 17, 2026 — selected offer checked 2026-11-17
- Case Connect: Signed Case Feed offer — checked November 17, 2026 — selected offer checked 2026-11-17
- Case Connect: separate first-15 promotion — checked November 17, 2026 — selected offer checked 2026-11-17
- Case Connect: website terms — checked November 17, 2026 — selected offer checked 2026-11-17
Tell us which cases your firm wants.
Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.
Discuss your case criteria