Vendor questions

What questions should a personal injury firm ask a case acquisition company before signing a contract?

Ask seven groups of questions before you sign: where claimants come from, what they consented to, who screens them, whose retainer they sign, what triggers payment, what happens when your firm declines a file, and how the arrangement fits your state’s rules on paying for clients. Get the answers written into the contract, not just said on a sales call. CaseLead Agency publishes this checklist and sells signed MVA cases at $2,800–$3,800 per standard retainer, so ask us all of these too.

Where do your claimants come from?

Sourcing is the first question because it decides your ethics and consumer-protection exposure. A vendor that buys from other vendors may not know what claimants were told. Ask for the actual ads and landing pages, not a description of them.

  • Which channels produce these claimants: paid social, paid search, TV, radio, or bought lists?
  • Do you generate every lead yourself, or do you buy from affiliates or other vendors? Name them.
  • Can we see the ads and landing pages running in our state before we start?
  • Do you ever contact people first, by phone, text or in person, or do they always come to you?
  • Do you use crash reports or hospital data to find people?

Who talks to the claimant, and what are they told?

Non-lawyer intake staff can gather facts. They should not give legal advice or promise an outcome. Ask to read the script and hear real calls, with client details removed if necessary.

  • Is intake done by your employees, a call center or an automated system?
  • May we read the intake script and listen to sample calls?
  • What are claimants told about who you are and how our firm is connected to you?
  • Do you ask about existing representation, and how do you record the answer?
  • Which answers do you verify, and which are simply what the claimant reported?

Whose agreement gets signed, and what record do we receive?

A “signed case” should mean the claimant signed your firm’s representation agreement. Ask how the signature is collected and what proof comes with the file.

  • Is the retainer our firm’s own agreement, in the version we supplied?
  • Who explains the agreement to the claimant before they sign, and what may that person say?
  • What signing record do we receive, and can we audit it?
  • How do you handle a claimant who says they did not understand what they signed?

What triggers payment?

This is the question that most changes your real cost. “Pay per signed case” can describe at least four different contracts.

AskA clear answerA warning sign
When is a fee owed?A named event, such as signature on our retainer or our acceptance“When the case is delivered,” with delivery left undefined
Do we prepay?The amount, what it covers and what happens to any unused balanceA large deposit described as non-refundable
Is media included?Stated either way, with an estimate if it is billed separatelyA monthly fee with ad spend mentioned only in small print
Is there a minimum?The order size and term, in the contractAn auto-renewing term found only in linked terms of use

What happens when we decline a file or the case falls apart?

Declined files will happen, so settle the process before the first delivery. Ask what counts as a valid reason, how long you have, and whether you get money back, a credit or a replacement.

  • How many days do we have to review a file, and when does that clock start?
  • Which reasons qualify: already represented, outside our criteria, no treatment, duplicate?
  • Is the remedy a refund, a credit or a replacement, and does it expire?
  • What if a client fires us or stops responding after we accept?

Who else gets this claimant?

“Exclusive” can mean one firm per claimant, one firm per territory or simply not resold this month. Write down which you are buying.

  • Is each claimant sent only to our firm, and can you show that?
  • Do you sell the same geography to other firms?
  • How do you treat a repeat inquiry, or a person already known to our firm?

How does this structure fit our state’s rules?

ABA Model Rule 7.2 lets a lawyer pay for advertising but not pay someone for recommending the lawyer. Comment [5] allows paying for client leads only if the lead generator does not recommend the lawyer, the payment is consistent with Rules 1.5(e) and 5.4, and its communications meet Rule 7.1. States differ on fees tied to a signed client. A vendor should be able to explain why its structure was chosen for your state. That explanation does not replace your own ethics counsel, who should read the contract.

  • Which states do you work in, and does the fee structure change by state?
  • Does the fee vary with whether a client signs or is retained?
  • Do your ads or scripts recommend our firm, or state that a lawyer is the best choice?
  • Has a bar, regulator or court questioned your program?

Questions law firms ask

What is the most important question to ask a lead vendor?

What exactly triggers payment, and what happens if your firm declines the file. Those two answers decide your true cost per accepted case more than the headline price.

Should a lawyer review a case acquisition contract?

Yes. Your ethics counsel should read the fee structure and the contact methods for each state, because rules on paying for clients differ and the lawyer carries the professional risk.

What if a vendor will not answer these questions?

Treat that as your answer. A provider that will not show its ads, intake script or consent language is asking you to carry risk you cannot see.

Does CaseLead answer these questions?

Yes. CaseLead Agency runs paid acquisition on Meta and Google, qualifies callers by telephone, completes human intake and coordinates your firm’s retainer. Standard signed MVA retainers cost $2,800–$3,800, and each written proposal states the billable event and review terms.

Sources and further reading

Your firm's acquisition brief

Tell us which cases your firm wants.

Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.

Discuss your case criteria