Red flags in how the vendor finds claimants
Start here, because these problems can land on your firm rather than the vendor.
| Red flag | Why it matters | What to ask for |
|---|---|---|
| Will not show ads or landing pages | You cannot judge what claimants were promised or whether the ads meet your state’s advertising rules | Live examples for your state, before you sign |
| “Proprietary sources” with no detail | Often means reselling, so nobody can trace consent | Whether any volume comes from affiliates or other vendors, by name |
| First contact comes from the vendor | Calling or visiting accident victims can raise solicitation, runner and capper issues | A written statement that claimants come to them, and how |
| Uses crash reports or hospital data | The marketing firms in Ohio’s 2026 Cable decision bought police reports to find accident victims, and Pennsylvania’s 18 Pa.C.S. § 4117(b) bars paying for identifying information about people treated after an accident | The exact data sources used to find people |
| No consent record | Calls and texts without provable consent can create TCPA exposure | A timestamped record and the exact form language |
Red flags in the contract
Read the linked terms as well as the proposal. Terms that contradict the sales pitch are themselves a warning.
- Payment is due at “delivery,” and delivery is not defined
- A large prepayment with no statement of what happens to undelivered cases
- Refunds are ruled out in terms of use while the sales page promises replacements
- Monthly program fees plus separately billed media, with no estimate of cost per signed case
- An automatic renewal or a term longer than the one you discussed
- A guaranteed number of signed cases with no remedy if it is missed
- No named review window, or one that starts before you actually receive the file
Red flags in the files you receive
If a test order is already running, look for these patterns. One bad file means little. A pattern means the program is not what was described.
- Claimants who do not remember the vendor, or do not recognize your firm’s name
- Claimants who already have a lawyer, or who say they were told otherwise
- Accident dates much older than your criteria allow, or close to the filing deadline
- No reported injury or treatment, or treatment that began only after the vendor’s call
- Several files with the same wording in the accident description
- The same claimant, phone number or address showing up twice
- A retainer signed on the wrong version of your agreement, or with no signing record
Red flags in the ethics and legal structure
ABA Model Rule 7.2 lets lawyers pay for advertising but not pay for a recommendation, and comment [5] says a lead generator must not imply that it is recommending the lawyer, making the referral without payment, or analyzing the person’s legal problem to pick a lawyer. Courts and bars have applied that line to per-client marketing fees. In Columbus Bar Assn. v. Cable (2026), two marketing firms bought police reports, solicited accident victims by phone and referred them to a lawyer who paid $75 to $300 per client. The Supreme Court of Ohio found violations including Rule 7.2(b) and imposed a one-year suspension, fully stayed on conditions. In New Jersey, Opinion 741 says lawyers may pay a set amount per lead but not per client retained. New York Opinion 1294 (March 2026) says a lead generator’s fee cannot change based on whether a client is retained.
So a vendor that says “this is legal everywhere” is showing you a red flag. A credible answer names your state, describes the fee structure used there and tells you to have your own ethics counsel review it. Our ethics guide summarizes the rules across 16 states.
Red flags in the sales pitch
Some claims should make you ask for evidence, and some should end the conversation.
- Guaranteed settlement values or case values, which nobody can honestly promise before investigation
- Very high sign rates with no definition of what counts as a lead or a signature
- A low per-case price with no explanation of why it is below the published market
- Case studies with no dates, no definitions and no way to reproduce the numbers
- Pressure to prepay this week because a territory is about to go
How do you test a vendor without taking on much risk?
Start with the smallest order the vendor allows, agree your criteria in writing and track every file from delivery to your decision. Call a sample of claimants yourself and ask how they found the vendor, what they were told and whether they understood what they signed. Then measure cost per accepted case rather than cost per delivered file.
CaseLead Agency, which publishes this guide, sells signed MVA cases at $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed retainer. Put our proposal through the same checks.
Questions law firms ask
What is the biggest red flag when buying personal injury leads?
A vendor that will not show where claimants come from or produce consent records. Everything else, including price and sign rate, depends on knowing how the claimant arrived.
Is a guarantee of signed cases a red flag?
It can be. Ask what happens if the number is missed, because a guarantee with no contract remedy is a sales claim. Ask also how a volume promise squares with your state’s rules on fees tied to signed clients.
Are resold leads always bad?
Not always, if you know you are buying shared leads and the price reflects it. The problem is paying for exclusivity and receiving a lead that other firms also got.
How can I tell if signed cases are real?
Call a sample of clients yourself. Ask whether they recognize your firm, understood the agreement and remember signing it. Compare the signing record to what they tell you.
Sources and further reading
Tell us which cases your firm wants.
Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.
Discuss your case criteria