Define what is changing before placing the replacement order
Write a transition brief that identifies the existing problem and the evidence that would show it is resolved. Missing source records, repeated duplicates and deliveries outside staffed hours require different corrections.
Specify whether you are changing only the provider or also the geography, delivery stage, case criteria or receiving team. Moving from forms to signed retainers changes the work included. Keep those differences visible so a later improvement is not automatically attributed to the provider change.
This guide concerns the overlap between an outgoing and incoming supplier. Use the acquisition pilot guide for the overall test design; the extra task here is to keep two delivery histories and one firm intake queue consistent.
Inventory the work that survives the last delivery
Create a dated transition register before issuing stop instructions. Record agreed terms and unresolved questions separately. Have the firm’s purchasing owner establish the permitted cutoff and continuing obligations from its actual agreement; this worksheet does not decide termination rights.
Name an owner and backup for every open item. Stopping new acquisition does not remove the need to handle existing inquiries under the firm’s process.
| Open item | Record before cutover | Accountable owner |
|---|---|---|
| Order and billing | Order IDs, unused balance, scheduled deliveries, outstanding invoice lines | Purchasing or finance |
| Intake work | Unreached inquiries, promised callbacks, pending signatures and firm reviews | Intake director |
| Exceptions | Disputed delivery IDs, evidence, deadlines and supplier acknowledgment | Supplier liaison |
| Future remedies | Approved but unposted credits and undelivered replacements | Finance |
| Receiving access | Routing destinations, export availability and access end dates | Operations |
Agree the boundary for deliveries already in progress
Use a timestamp and time zone. Ask the outgoing provider to distinguish acquisition stopped, delivery stopped and completion of already-authorized work. Record which person confirms each event and where the confirmation is stored.
Clarify the treatment of late packets, scheduled calls and corrected files. A packet completed before cutoff but received afterward needs classification under the agreed rule. Do not move its receipt time or delete it to make the old order look finished.
Keep a late-delivery queue with a named reviewer. Receipt there should not automatically create a new billable order or trigger fresh claimant outreach. Resolve the delivery’s status against the agreement and preserve the resolution.
Give every active inquiry one contact owner
Before overlap begins, assign a firm-side owner for each existing person and incident. Keep scheduled callbacks, prior messages, recorded preferences and outstanding promises visible in the approved intake system. The new supplier should not independently restart contact merely because it received a matching record.
For a possible match, pause duplicate routing and have the designated owner inspect the records. Shared phone numbers and similar names need review; they are not sufficient proof that two records describe the same person and incident.
Agree which party handles updates and how contact restrictions reach that party through the firm’s approved process. Transfer only the access and information needed for the assigned work. Keep the firm’s review and client-care decisions separate from a commercial supplier switch.
Preserve two delivery records and one inquiry history
Keep each supplier’s delivery ID, original receipt timestamp, source description, criteria version and invoice reference. Link matching deliveries to a stable firm inquiry ID. Merging the person record must not erase which supplier delivered it or what either supplier charged.
Compare duplicates across the existing inquiry history, not only this week’s replacement order. Record the match evidence and commercial duplicate definition that applies. An operational duplicate and a credit-eligible duplicate are separate decisions.
Treat an updated packet as a version of its original delivery. Treat a replacement as a linked delivery with its own ID. Never change source ownership retrospectively merely to make the incoming provider’s dashboard agree with finance.
Test the failure paths before increasing overlap
Use synthetic records in an agreed test workflow. Confirm that the firm can identify the inquiry, prevent a second contact assignment and preserve both supplier records. Have finance trace the same test through invoice reconciliation.
| Test record | Expected handling | Evidence to retain |
|---|---|---|
| New unique inquiry | Assign the agreed owner and preserve incoming source | Routing event and receiving owner |
| Inquiry already active with old provider | Flag possible duplicate before new outreach | Match decision and contact owner |
| Old packet corrected after cutoff | Attach a new version to the original delivery | Original receipt plus correction time |
| Late new delivery from old provider | Send to the exception owner | Cutoff rule and disposition |
| Replacement for old disputed file | Link original and replacement; check billing | Two delivery IDs and remedy record |
Compare the replacement using accepted cases and open work
Consider a fictional checkpoint after equal observation time. Provider A delivered 20 unique matters: 10 accepted, six declined and four pending. Its attributable charges were $12,000, with $2,000 in posted credits and $1,000 of recorded intake cost. Cost per accepted matter is ($12,000 − $2,000 + $1,000) ÷ 10 = $1,100.
Provider B delivered 20 unique matters: 12 accepted, four declined and four pending. Its charges were $14,000 with no posted credits and $1,600 of intake cost. Cost per accepted matter is ($14,000 + $1,600) ÷ 12 = $1,300. B has the higher accepted share, 60% versus 50%, but the higher observed acquisition cost per accepted matter.
These invented numbers are not targets or evidence about either provider. Preserve pending files, define cost allocation and compare case mix and delivery stage before choosing. Unposted credit requests remain separate from net cost. With no accepted matters, report costs and counts instead of a zero cost per acceptance.
Write separate cutover and closeout decisions
Set firm-specific gates before overlap: required source records must be accessible, duplicate routing must resolve to one owner, agreed delivery hours must work and intake must have capacity. A failed routing test calls for a correction before adding volume.
At the checkpoint, authorize a specific next scope and review date only if the records support it. If case mix, incomplete reviews or staffing changes prevent a fair comparison, keep the decision provisional. A lower unit price alone does not resolve the switch.
Close the old relationship operationally after the final delivery list, continuing intake ownership, credits and replacements reconcile. Preserve exports and necessary audit history under the firm’s retention process. The new-provider ramp and old-provider financial closeout can occur on different dates.
Questions law firms ask
Should we run both providers at the same time?
Overlap can expose duplicate and routing problems, but adds workload. Use a bounded overlap only when the firm can preserve delivery history, assign one contact owner and review the files.
Who gets credit when both providers deliver the same inquiry?
Preserve both deliveries and their evidence. Apply the attribution rule and each agreement’s billing terms separately; a CRM source field does not settle a duplicate-charge dispute.
Does a higher sign rate prove the replacement is better?
No. Compare the same delivery stage, case profile and observation window, with pending work visible. Firm acceptance and attributable intake cost answer different questions from signatures alone.
Sources and further reading
Tell us which cases your firm wants.
Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.
Discuss your case criteria