Vendor credits and replacements

How do personal injury firms track rejected leads and get credits or replacements from lead vendors?

Log every delivered lead or file with its delivery time, the criterion it failed, your evidence and the date you disputed it. File the dispute inside the vendor’s window, which ranges from 72 hours to 14 days among providers that publish one. Tie each credit or replacement to the original delivery so nothing is counted twice, and reconcile against the invoice every month. Most sellers offer a replacement or credit rather than cash, and some say all sales are final, so read the terms before your first order.

What are lead vendors’ published return and replacement terms?

From each provider’s own website, checked November 3, 2026. Where pages conflict, we say so. Your contract controls, so confirm these before you order.

ProviderWindowRemedyNote
CaseLead Agency (publisher of this page)Set in each agreementSet in each agreementYour proposal states the review window and terms
InjuryLeads.io72 hoursFree replacementLists no setup fees or minimums to start
Claim Supply72 hours for leads; 14 days for signed retainersReplaced, not refunded in cashOrder based, with no automatic renewal
MVA LeadsNot statedCredit on the next invoice, or 1:1 replacement within 48 hours on plansCovers wrong state, uninjured, represented or unreachable leads
On Point Legal Leads5 daysExchanged for creditAlso offers help if a claimant cannot be reached within a week
getMVA5 days for credit requests; 8-day review7-day replacement with a drop letterCash refunds generally not provided
Injury Case Claims7 daysFree replacement if approvedIts retainer page also describes a window agreed before launch
Mass Tort Marketing Agency7 daysReplacementFees for periods with work performed are non-refundable
First Intent Leads14 days on signed casesReplacement or creditIts homepage also advertises a 7-day case review
Case ConnectPayment due 14 days after deliveryFull credit if criteria failIts main site says the agreement sets the credit terms
Injury Lead GenNot stated hereInvalid leads replaced with equal valueAll sales final; payments non-refundable
Legal Leads Group (Lucrative Legal)Not publishedNo refund policyIts terms say all payments are final

What should a rejection log include?

Keep one row per delivered lead or file, in one place. A shared spreadsheet is enough if everyone uses it the same way.

FieldExample
Vendor and orderVendor name, order or invoice number
Matter ID and delivery timeVendor’s ID, and the time you received it
Stage reachedContacted, screened, signed, reviewed
DecisionAccepted, declined or pending
Reason codeOne code from your agreed list
EvidenceCall recording, note or document that supports the code
Dispute deadlineDelivery date plus the vendor’s window
Dispute date and resultWhen filed, and credited, replaced or denied
Replacement linkThe original matter this one replaces

Which rejection reasons should you use?

Agree the codes with the vendor before the first delivery, and use the same wording as your contract. Vague reasons such as “bad lead” are easy for a vendor to deny.

  • Already represented
  • Outside the agreed state or county
  • No reported injury or treatment
  • Accident outside the agreed date range
  • Claimant not at fault under your criteria
  • Duplicate of a lead you already received
  • Wrong or disconnected phone number
  • Claimant denies making the request
  • Unreachable after the agreed number of attempts

How do you actually get the credit?

Name one person who files disputes, and give them a weekly deadline report. Vendors’ windows are short, and the most common way to lose a credit is to miss the date. Send the matter ID, the reason code and the evidence, and record the vendor’s answer in the same row.

At month end, compare the log with the invoice line by line. Then calculate your cost per accepted case using only confirmed credits, not ones you have merely requested, and keep pending matters out of the accepted count.

How does CaseLead handle declined files?

CaseLead Agency writes the review window, duplicate handling and any credit or replacement terms into each agreement, and your firm decides whether to accept each file. Standard signed MVA retainers cost $2,800–$3,800. Ask us to show you those terms in the proposal, and hold us to the same log.

Questions law firms ask

Can you get a refund from a personal injury lead vendor?

Usually you get a replacement or a credit rather than cash. Some sellers state that all sales are final, so check the refund policy before you buy.

How long do you have to dispute a bad lead?

Published windows run from 72 hours to 14 days. Some vendors publish no window at all, so get yours in writing and track it per lead.

What counts as a bad personal injury lead?

Whatever your contract says. Common grounds include already represented, wrong state, no injury, a duplicate or a disconnected number. A lead that simply does not sign rarely qualifies.

Should credits count in cost per accepted case?

Only confirmed ones. Subtract credits you actually received from the same delivery group, and report pending disputes separately.

Sources and further reading

Your firm's acquisition brief

Tell us which cases your firm wants.

Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.

Discuss your case criteria