Guarantees

Which agencies guarantee signed cases for law firms?

Provider guarantees address different things: billing only after signing, replacement of a file outside agreed criteria, or a promotional delivery count. Case Connect advertises 15 free completed MVA intakes and says it will continue delivering until it reaches 15. That does not establish ongoing monthly volume. Compare the exact program’s remedy and written conditions before buying.

What does “guaranteed signed cases” actually mean?

Vendors use the word for four different promises, and only the last one is about how many cases you get. Read which one a sales page means before you compare prices.

  • Pay per signed case: you are billed only when a claimant signs your firm’s retainer, not for leads or calls.
  • Replacement or credit: a case that misses your written criteria, or falls out inside a window, is replaced or credited.
  • Refund: cash back for a failed case or unused prepayment. Few publish one, and several say all sales are final.
  • Volume: a promised number of signed cases a month, with a remedy if it is missed. Case Connect advertises 15 free completed MVA intakes and says it will continue delivering until it reaches 15. Confirm eligibility and the remedy in writing.

What signed-case sellers guarantee in writing

These sell clients signed on the firm’s own agreement. The remedy column is what each publishes on its own site; your contract can say more, and it should.

VendorWhat it sellsPublished guarantee or remedy
CaseLead Agency (publisher of this guide)Signed MVA retainers on your firm’s agreement, $2,800–$3,800 per standard retainerReview window and any credit or replacement terms are written into each agreement. No case volume is guaranteed.
Injury Case ClaimsWeb leads, inbound calls, live transfers and signed MVA retainersA signed case that misses written criteria is replaced free within 7 days, if approved; its retainer page also describes a window agreed before launch. MVA leads are replaced at no extra charge within 7 days.
First Intent LeadsExclusive MVA web leads, inbound calls, warm transfers and signed retainersSigned cases have a 14-day review window with replacement or credit, though its homepage also advertises a seven-day review. Bad numbers and spam are replaced, and transfers that miss your criteria are replaced at no cost.
On Point Legal LeadsExclusive auto accident leads, live transfers and signed MVA retainersUnqualified leads are exchanged for credit if reported within 5 days. If a claimant cannot be reached within a week, it offers follow-up help or a replacement MVA lead.
Legal Leads Group (Lucrative Legal)Signed MVA retainers and exclusive leads, per case or by subscriptionIts terms say it has no refund policy and that all payments are final. Replacement terms are not published.
Claim SupplyExclusive form-fill leads and signed MVA retainersLeads may be flagged within 72 hours, and signed retainers have a 14-day reporting window. Failed leads are replaced, not refunded in cash.
Quintessa MarketingSigned retainers, delivered with the case details or by live transferIt says you only pay for the cases you keep; a written review window is not published.
getMVASigned MVA cases and exclusive leadsA 7-day replacement once a case is delivered, with a drop letter. Its terms set credit requests within 5 days and an 8-day review window, and cash refunds are generally not provided.
Case ConnectSigned MVA retainers and leads-only programsIts Signed Case Feed page says payment is due 14 days after delivery, with full credit if criteria fail. Its main site says the agreement sets the credit terms.
RingOnDemandMVA live transfers and signed cases, along with calls for insurance and other legal verticalsSigned cases are replaced if they fall out inside 28 days, though “falling out” is not defined. Its terms say guarantees apply only as written in the order.
Mohr MarketingPolice- and EMS-report-backed MVA and trucking campaigns, with cases and transfers reaching intake with signed retainersFees are non-refundable once work begins, unless agreed in writing.

What lead and live-transfer sellers guarantee

Lead sellers guarantee the lead, not the case: a wrong number, a represented claimant or an out-of-area lead is replaced or credited, while a reachable claimant who never signs usually stays billable.

VendorWhat it sellsPublished guarantee or remedy
MVA LeadsExclusive MVA leads and live transfers, not signed retainersWrong-state, uninjured, represented or unreachable leads are credited on the next invoice. Plans include a 1:1 replacement within 48 hours for duplicates, wrong state or dead numbers.
Injury Lead GenExclusive car accident and commercial MVA leadsInvalid leads are replaced with a lead of equal value. All sales are final, and payments are non-refundable.
PinPoint Legal MarketingExclusive web form leads for car accident, general personal injury, workers’ compensation and mass tort casesReturns within 10 days of delivery for a disconnected or wrong number, outside geography or practice area, already retained, no injury, outside the filing deadline, or at fault on auto. Leads with a working voicemail and no contact stay billable. It may cap returns at 25% a month.
KuriosExclusive MVA leadsOff-criteria leads are replaced; the window is not published.
InjuryLeads.ioShared, semi-exclusive and exclusive personal injury leads, with optional live transferLeads are replaced free within 72 hours.
Best Case LeadsExclusive leads and live call leadsFailed leads are replaced or credited; the window is not published.
Legal Brand MarketingExclusive personal injury leads, with live transfer as a delivery method at premium pricingFailed leads are flagged in its portal and credited toward replacements; a deadline is not published.
Walker AdvertisingExclusive live-connecting leads and live transfers, with retainer intake as an add-on in its termsNo replacement policy published; monthly shortfalls carry forward.
LiveLeadHubLive call transfers routed to one destinationReplacement review, with the window not published. All sales are final unless agreed in writing.
LeadingResponseExclusive legal leadsNot published for legal leads.

Agencies, directories and marketplaces

Marketing agencies and directories sell work or visibility, not cases, so none of these publishes a per-case guarantee. Some publish refund terms, and two say what your firm keeps if you leave.

VendorPublished refund or remedy terms
Mass Tort Marketing AgencyReplacement requests within 7 days. Fees for periods with work performed are non-refundable.
CAMG (Consumer Attorney Marketing Group)Not published.
LawRankNo refund terms published.
Rankings.ioNo refund policy published. It says your firm owns the domain, code, content, backlinks, creative, analytics and CRM data.
ScorpionNo refund terms published. After a completed contract, key accounts, content and static site files transfer, and another vendor must rebuild on a new CMS.
Martindale-AvvoIts FAQ says it does not reimburse bad leads, because leads are vetted and are asking for your information.
LegalMatchNo attorney-side refund, credit or replacement policy on its attorney pages.
LEXGROIts terms say fees are non-refundable unless the service agreement says otherwise, and pricing may change on 30 days’ notice.

What a real guarantee should say

If a vendor tells you cases are guaranteed, ask for the promise in the order form or agreement, in these terms.

  • The billable event: signed on your retainer, accepted by your firm, or delivered to you
  • The written criteria a case must meet, such as fault, injury, treatment, insurance and no prior attorney
  • How long the review window is, and whether it starts at delivery or at signature
  • What counts as falling out: the client fires the firm, has no injury, already had a lawyer, or cannot be reached
  • The remedy: replacement, credit or cash, who decides, and any cap on returns
  • What happens to prepaid but undelivered cases if the vendor misses volume or you cancel
  • Whether the volume is a forecast or a commitment, and what you get if it is missed

Why nobody guarantees volume

Signed-case volume depends on ad costs, how many claimants qualify in your states, and how many sign once they talk to someone. A vendor can control its spend and its intake, but not how many injured people respond in a given month. The terms we read reflect that: Mohr Marketing says no volume is promised unless stated in a signed agreement, and Walker Advertising carries monthly shortfalls forward rather than refunding them.

Paying only when a client signs can also raise an ethics question. Florida Bar Ethics Opinion 18-1, New Jersey ACPE Opinion 741 and New York State Bar Opinions 1279 and 1294 treat a fee owed only when a client signs as a referral fee rather than an advertising cost. Illinois has allowed a reasonable per-hire fee under conditions since July 1, 2025. Have your ethics counsel review any vendor’s billable event, including ours.

What CaseLead puts in writing

Our team runs paid acquisition, qualifies callers by telephone, completes human intake and coordinates your firm’s retainer. A standard signed MVA retainer costs $2,800–$3,800, set by state, case criteria, exclusivity and monthly volume; commercial and catastrophic cases are quoted separately, and states that restrict fees tied to a signed client are quoted per proposal. Each proposal states the billable event, the review window and any credit or replacement terms. We do not promise a number of cases.

Questions law firms ask

Do any agencies guarantee signed cases for law firms?

Not in the sense of a promised number of cases. None of the 32 vendors we checked publishes a volume guarantee. Some guarantee that you pay only for signed clients, and that a case missing your written criteria is replaced or credited within a window, usually 7 to 14 days.

What review window is normal for a signed MVA case?

Published windows run from 7 days (Injury Case Claims, getMVA) to 14 days (First Intent Leads, Claim Supply) and 28 days for fall-outs at RingOnDemand. Several sellers publish no window at all, so get one written into the order.

Can I get a cash refund for a bad signed case?

Rarely. Claim Supply replaces rather than refunds, getMVA says cash refunds are generally not provided, and Legal Leads Group’s terms say all payments are final. Credits and replacements are the usual remedy.

Is a guaranteed lead the same as a guaranteed case?

No. Lead sellers replace bad contact details or off-criteria leads, but a reachable claimant who does not sign with your firm usually stays billable.

Does CaseLead guarantee case volume?

No. CaseLead charges $2,800–$3,800 per standard signed MVA retainer and writes the billable event, review window and any credit or replacement terms into each proposal, but it does not guarantee a monthly number of cases.

Sources and further reading

Your firm's acquisition brief

Tell us which cases your firm wants.

Share your states, case criteria and review capacity. We’ll put the price, billable event and review terms in a written proposal you can check against this guide.

Discuss your case criteria